“Tara,” Dominic said.
Of course, Aidan thought. Tara had stitched up the wounds. She’d been taking care of Brigid the same way she’d been taking care of him and everyone else on the island. Why had he felt the need to give her such a hard time? It wasn’t just guilt he felt, now. It was shame.
“She’s been keeping it oiled all these years in case…” Dominic trailed off.
“In case our mother ever needed it again,” Liam finished for him.
Aidan fought the urge to reach out and touch it again. “Does she know you have this?”
“She knows,” Dominic said.
“How long has she known?”
“We told her the day she got here,” Dominic said. “We would never have kept it from her if she’d asked for it.”
“But that would have been almost seven years ago,” Aidan said. “Why hasn’t she asked for it until now?”
Liam exchanged a look with Dominic. “I think she’s been waiting.”
“For what?”
“For you.”
Aidan drew in a breath.
“I think she wanted to find you first,” Liam went on, “to make sure you were okay.”
It was only a theory, Aidan thought. But what if Liam was right? What if this was all about him?
Brigid had been fine before he’d gotten here. Neil had said that she’d only begun to regress three or four weeks ago. And Kelsey had said that whenever roses appeared on this island, it meant someone’s time was running out.
What if he was the one who’d set this ticking clock in motion?
“When I think about how angry I was at her for so many years…” Dominic shook his head. “I can’t believe I ever thought she abandoned us. I should have known better. I should have known something must have happened.”
That something, according to Brigid, was that she’d given birth to a child who’d been stolen from her, then she’d been institutionalized, where the grief of losing that child, the panic at being separated from her other two children, and the drugs she’d been forced to take had slowly eroded her sanity.
Aidan hadn’t wanted to believe it before. He hadn’t been able to believe it. Because as far-fetched as that part of her story was, it wasn’t nearly as hard to accept as the idea that she might be a selkie—and that magic did, in fact, exist in this world. He’d put that wall up to keep himself from having to believe the rest of the story. But if he let that wall come down, then he had to accept the possibility that the rest of her story might be true.
Which meant…
He looked up at Dominic. Then at Liam. He’d come here to apologize, to tell them that he wasn’t related to them, and that he’d been using them ever since he’d arrived. But he couldn’t find the words. He couldn’t seem to speak at all anymore. All he could hear was Grace’s voice, over and over, in his head: ‘The resemblance is unmistakable.’
She was right. It was unmistakable. He hadn’t wanted to see it, or admit it, before. But it was right there. It had been there all along. Dominic and Liam were his brothers.
And if Dominic and Liam were his brothers, then Brigid was…
“Is this really all we get?” Dominic’s gaze dropped to the pelt. “Seven years?”
“I feel like we just found her,” Liam said, his tone as heartbroken as his brother’s.
No, Aidan thought. They hadn’t just found her. They’d had her for seven years. And he could have had her, too, if he hadn’t ignored every attempt the O’Sullivans had made to reach out to him.
Why couldn’t he have returned one of their calls or responded to one of their emails? Why had he waited so long to come here? What was wrong with him?
He could hear Grace’s voice in his head again: ‘What are you so afraid of?’
He’d shut down, earlier, when she’d asked him that. Because the question hadn’t just struck a nerve. It had cut to the very core of his identity. At nine years old, he’d become a child no one had wanted. No one had ever come close to adopting him after his parents had died. And there was only one lens through which he’d been able to see the world after that—one where no one else would ever want him again.