"Liv," Lucy says gently.
I look up, meeting her gaze.
"Cliff is . . . kind of like a twenty-year-old kid. He has no idea what he wants. He’s just figuring everything out for himself." She blinks several times, and I realize my sister is on the verge of tears. "He’s missed the most important years of his life," she whispers. "He’s, like, emotionally stunted—and it’s all my fault."
I grab her hand, squeezing. "No. It’s not your fault! Cliff made that choice himself."
"He did it for me!" Her voice breaks. Tears rolls down her cheeks.
It kind of freaks me out. I don’t think I’ve ever seen Lucy cry. I push the tissues back her way. "He’s still the one who did it. I’m sure he knew what the consequences would be." I glower. He sure as hell better know what the consequences are now. I am never, ever letting him back in. "Asshole," I mutter.
Lucy dries her tears. "So what happened?" she says, voice thick with emotion.
I know she’s just trying to deflect the conversation away from her, but I’m drunk and too clumsy to bat it back at her. "He went on about how he’s so dangerous and blah, blah, blah." I roll my eyes, my voice too loud. "Basically, the whole 'you’re too good for me' spiel."
"Pathetic." She crosses her arms. "Well, his loss."
My pursed lips twitch to the side.
"What?" Lucy peers at me. "It is his loss, Olivia."
"Then why," I draw out the word, "does it feel like mine?" I huff. This is all too weird. I’m not used to men turning my world upside down and inside out. I feel like someone’s slit my body open and rearranged all of my organs. It’s not a nice feeling, and it has nothing to do with the wine.
"You’ve got to focus on you, Livvie," my sister says in her preachy I know better because I’m so much older voice. "You have so much to offer in a relationship. Anyone who doesn’t see that is . . . is . . ."
"Even if he’s your childhood hero?" I scowl, eyeing the bottle of wine. There’s enough left for one glass.
"Go for it." She pushes it toward me. "Look, Cliff may be like a brother to me, but you are my sister. Hos before bros, yo."
Cringing, I pour my glass. "Please don’t ever say that again."
She shrugs. "But it’s true. And you do have a lot to give—to someone who’s really going to appreciate it."
"A lot to give? Luce, I’ve missed like seventy-five percent of my classes this week. I’m behind on my internship hours." I lift my voice into a southern twang. "My daddy’s in prison." I giggle. "I’m a fucking country song."
"Too bad college radio stations don’t usually play country," she jokes.
"Maybe they do down south." I tilt my head, pretending to contemplate. "I could move to Georgia or something, redo the semester . . ."
"You’re a sneeze away from graduating." Lucy stands and puts her hands on her hips. "Don’t you dare throw it all away over some guy."
If only she knew.
I rest my chin in the palm of my hand. "I wish I could go back in time." Add/drop that damn photography class. Or just never accept the camera from Eli. And definitely, for sure, not have sex with Cliff in someone’s station wagon. I fold my arms on the table and bury my face in my sweater.
"Let me drive you home," Lucy says, rubbing my back. "It’ll all look better in the morning. I promise."
I snort. "Like you’re even sober enough to drive." My voice is muffled against the table.
"Pfft. How do you think I get through my week with these kids?"
Sitting up fast, I twist around to see her face. A smirk dances across her lips. "Luce, that’s like borderline alcoholism."
She rolls her eyes. "I don’t drink to function, Livvie. I have one or two glasses every night, after dinner and while I correct papers. It’s my way of celebrating surviving another day in educational hell." She sighs. "I thought this teaching gig was going to be so different, you know?"
"You," I say, poking her in the ribs, "are ruining your own 'graduate in time' lecture."
She smoothes my hair. "You’re going to find that the world doesn’t always meet your expectations. And that feeling, my friend, is called disillusionment. Learn to love wine." She pats my back. "Now come on. I’ve got to get up early, and I’m sure your kitty wants his territory back."