“You announced it before anyone knew there was another choice.”
I take in the spot where the bills used to sit. “I knew what we could afford.”
“So did I.”
“Then what are we arguing about?”
“Nobody told you no, Caleb.”
“Dad told me I needed a future that could carry me. Ma told me to do something that paid and draw later.”
“They were scared about money. That isn’t the same as refusing you.”
“Would they have found thirty grand in the sofa?”
“No.” Her answer comes without hesitation. “It would have been hard. Maybe it would not have worked. Maybe you would have needed loans, aid, a job, or a different school. I don’t know what they would have said because you made sure none of us had the conversation.”
The refrigerator hums. Heat knocks once through the old pipes.
Sienna turns the wineglass by its stem. “Dad thought you wanted hockey.”
“I did.”
“I know. You wanted art too.”
I look down at my hands. Dad’s hands. The scar across my right knuckle catches the light from the stove.
“Ma knew you drew,” she continues. “She didn’t know how hard you worked on the portfolio. Dad didn’t know your teacher helped you apply. You gave them the answer before you showed them what it cost.”
“I saved everybody the trouble.”
“Yeah.” Sienna’s voice goes quiet. “You’re good at that.”
Last night, I put Lila into a cab for the same reason.
I have called that practical for eight years. Sitting at this table, it looks a lot more like fear.
Sienna finishes her wine and stands. “Ma kept your school papers in the hall closet. Top shelf.”
“Why?”
“Because she’s Ma.” Sienna picks up the wrapped package. “Eat something before you go to sleep.”
She reaches the doorway, then turns back. “Lila came here, Caleb.”
“I know.”
“Then act like it.”
She leaves before I can answer.
The hall closet is packed with winter coats and three white file boxes labeled in Ma’s handwriting. SIENNA—SCHOOL. CALEB—SCHOOL. HOUSE.
Mine is on the top shelf.
I carry it to the kitchen and set it beside the half-wrapped Christmas gifts. Report cards fill the front. Team pictures, medical forms, a disciplinary notice from ninth grade that still feels unfair.
Near the bottom, the cream envelope lies beneath a stack of college brochures.