My fingers tightened around the edge of the door, the wood grounding me.
“You shouldn’t be here.”
“I know.” His voice was hoarse, edged with something almost fragile. “But I came anyway.”
A gust of cold air swept past us. I stepped back just enough for the door to drift wider.
“What do you want?”
He hesitated—but only for a heartbeat.
“This…” he said, then reached into his coat and pulled out a folded piece of paper, its edges softened from being handled too many times.
“This letter your father gave to me,” he said, holding it tightly.
My blood ran cold. The house was so silent I could hear the faint tremor in the paper as he extended it toward me.
I didn’t take it.
“Why?” I asked, confused as to why my father would send Aristotle Hades a letter.
His eyes met mine. And despite everything—despite the fear, the memories, the ache that had never fully healed—I saw the truth there.
“Because,” he whispered, “someone is coming for you, and your father knows I’m the only one who could protect you, Sophia Sutton.”
Chapter forty-four
Aristotle
Idon’t remember the walk to her house, only the rage that had pulled me there, step after step. The porch light was off, but a faint glow spilled through her bedroom window and the living room curtains.
She was here.
Alive.
I’d been watching her ever since she showed up at the morgue to see her father. Before he died, he’d warned me that someone was after him. He’d felt eyes on him, too. My hand tightened around the letter hidden in my coat pocket, the one he’d given me after making me swear not to open it until he was gone.
I raised my fist to knock, then hesitated.
For one pathetic moment, I stood there like a man who had forgotten how to breathe. My body seemed to understand the danger of seeing her again, even if my heart refused to acknowledge it.
Still, I knocked.
Her footsteps approached—soft, familiar, and sharp enough to tear through every wall I’d spent years building around myself.
When the door opened, the dim light behind her spilled across her face, carving shadows along her cheekbones. Shock flashed in her eyes, followed by something I couldn't quite name.
Something that made me want to reach for her.
Something that reminded me I had no right to.
“How are you feeling?” I asked softly.
The question sounded pathetic the moment it left my mouth. As if I had any right to ask how she was feeling after everything I’d done. As if six months in treatment and years of drowning myself in guilt could somehow make up for the pain I’d caused her.
I stayed where I was. I could’ve walked past her, demanded answers, and forced her to listen to everything I’d kept buried for years.
God, I wanted to.