“Says the man who’s been out with one woman ever.”
“Hey, we aren’t talking about me right now,” I defend. “Is everything okay?”
“Yeah,” he says, but something in his voice tells me in no way is it fine. “I just haven’t wanted to.”
It’s because of Ellie. I know it. I just don’t know if he’s connected the dots that he hasn’t dated because he’s in love with a woman who doesn’t know about his feelings for her.
“Don’t bite my head off when I ask you this. But, is it because of her?”
I figure he’ll skate the question, so I’m shocked when he answers truthfully.
“Yeah…it is.”
If he admitted any of this during Poker Club, Beau and Maddox would be all over him. Hell, I’d probably join in, too. The fact he’s trusting me with it now confirms I made the right choice in calling him.
We’ve never met Ellie—he’s been very careful to keep that side of his life separate—but the way he talks about her when she does come up, even a blind man could see he’s in love with her.
He insists she’s just a friend. Yet, she decorated his condo. He built her bookshelves. He’s the man of honor at her wedding. And she’s the one who’s going to get away because he won’t make the move.
“I get the not wanting to,” I say. “Believe me, if anyone understands that, it’s me.”
“Thanks,” he says, relieved I’m not pushing the subject. “If I’m still your pick for advice, what were you thinking?”
I can tell he needs a change of subject, so I oblige. “I’m not sure. Dinner? Movie? Mini golf?”
“Are you a professional athlete or the captain of the high school hockey team?” he asks jokingly.
I push down my immediate response to tell him to fuck himself. “Listen, the last time I went on a first date that’s what I did. And yes, I was the captain.”
“That was my only joke, I promise,” Theo says. “Did you have other ideas?”
“Not really. I looked for ideas on Google, but they were all shit.”
Theo chuckles. “Care to share those recommendations so I know what to eliminate?”
“Most of them were to go to a bar or distillery. There was a bowling place that looked kind of fun, but I’m not sure if she’s into that kind of thing. Coffee feels boring. Also, what is Color Me Mine?”
“Something I doubt you’d enjoy,” he says. “What does Sutton like? That’ll help narrow things down.”
I suck in a breath, hoping Theo didn’t hear it. Because, if this were real, how much should I know about a woman I’m dating this early in the relationship? “This is still new, so I’m not sure. We’re still getting to know each other.”
“That’s fine. Slow and steady. What is it you do know?”
“I know she likes cinnamon rolls and cutting hair.”
“Well, that last one is her job, so we’re not doing that. Oh! Maybe you can sneak her into the bakery. Tell her your deep, dark, secret. Wait! Even better idea. Have her show you how she made that denim jacket. I bet you’d be a whiz with a Bedazzler.”
“I should’ve called Maddox,” I groan.
“Okay, I’m sorry,” he says. “What are some of her interests? Anything randomly come up in conversation?”
I think about it for a second. I know she likes hanging with her kid and her favorite color is yellow, but neither of those help. She doesn’t always love her family—which, I can’t blame her for that one.
“She likes hockey,” I say.
“If you could only take her to a game,” Theo says.
“Well that would solve everything,” I say, but just as I’m ready to move on to the next idea, one pops in my head that I never would’ve thought about on my own. Not in a million years. But it just might work.