Nothing much. I’m off at the salon on Mondays. Probably wedding stuff so my sister doesn’t get on my ass about things. Why? What’s up?
I take a breath before I type these next words. Words I knew I’d type, or say, one day, but didn’t know it would be now.
Okay, Hailey, if this is you pulling the strings, then I hope this is okay…
Me
Do you want to go out on a date with me? Just the two of us? You know, so we can get to know each other since this is now out in the open?
My hands shook the entire time I typed that message, which is silly. But they stop the second I read three little words.
Sutton
I’d love to.
CHAPTER 18
ASHER
“Hey man. Everything okay?”
Theo’s response isn’t unexpected. I’m not much of a talk-on-the-phone guy. When I do start communication, it’s almost always through text. But what I need to ask him doesn’t feel like a text conversation.
“Yeah, everything’s fine.” I pause and take a deep breath. “Can I ask you something?”
“Of course.”
“What does— Where do… I mean, how do I…” Why can’t I get these words out? “I want to take Sutton on a date. And since you do this more than I do, I thought maybe you could help.”
There. I said it. And he’s not laughing at me, which is a good thing. But that’s also why I called Theo. Beau would’ve been helpful after he gave me shit for a few minutes. Maddox would’ve been so excited he’d forget to give me advice. And Liam and Finn would’ve made too much of a deal out of it, probably showing up with ridiculous mustaches to try and spy on us.
Theo’s the safe one. He’s single, actively dating, and even though he’s like Maddox and can get overly-excited, he knows when to rein it in.
“Wow, I’m flattered you asked,” he says. “Are you sure I’m the one you want to talk to? Why not Maddox. He’s young and hip.”
“You’re three years older than him.”
“That’s a big age difference. He says words I don’t understand. Gen Z-ers, you know?”
“You’re Gen-Z.”
“Barely. But yeah, for the fun things you should really ask Maddox. Or what about your teammates?”
This makes no sense. Theo is the king of advice. Always wanting to steer people in the right direction. If he wasn’t a professional baseball player, he could’ve made a serious run at becoming a life coach. And now I’m asking him to actually help me with something and he’s balking? Something’s not adding up.
“I could, but I’m asking you. Unless there’s a reason you don’t want to give me advice, which, in the history of the time I’ve known you, has never happened.”
“I’m just… I don’t know if I’m the guy to ask for dating advice.”
“Why not? You’re single. Good looking. You’ve talked plenty of times about women you’ve taken out.”
“I have. All of that is correct. Except…I haven’t dated recently.”
“Really? And so we’re on the same page, what does not recently look like to you?”
“A year.”
I have to blink my eyes a few times. “You haven’t been on a date in a year?”