My stomach turns at that thought. I mean, I know they did. They have Maverick. But still, it’s not something I want to think about.
“If they want me to have a date, then I’m going to have a date. And if it pisses Rob off in the process, because you know he’s going to be pissed, I think that’s a winner in my book.”
I laugh at her attitude about it. “So you are petty.”
She coyly shrugs. “Only if they deserve it.”
We stop and share a smile as Gabi comes over to check on us. “Do you two need anything before I close up? Then again, if this is going well, whatever this is, I can stay open for you guys. As long as you need.”
She really is one of the good ones. “I’m good. Just the check and a Rice Krispie treat for Adalyn.”
“Oh! Can I get one of those for Mav, too? He loved the last one you brought him.”
“Put that on my bill,” I say, but Gabi laughs me off.
“Funny that either of you two think you’re paying. I’ll be right back.”
She walks off, but not before giving us a knowing wink.
“It looks as if she at least thinks this is a date,” Sutton whispers. “That’s a good sign.”
“It is,” I say. “Are you going to be upset if we don’t tell anyone what this agreement is?”
Sutton shakes her head. “It’ll be hard, but I think the fewer people who know, the better.”
“Agree. I feel like even one person knowing has the potential to make this an avalanche. It’s probably easier if it’s all or nothing.”
I wait for Sutton to say something back, but she doesn’t, instead standing up and grabbing her purse.
“Where are you going?”
She nods toward the door. “If no one is going to know, then we shouldn’t talk about this at a place of business where you know the owner. An owner who is probably already telling your friends that we met here, and not just for an innocent cup of coffee and a pastry.”
“Shit. You’re right,” I say, quickly standing up. God, I’m already horrible at this. “What are you thinking?”
“I’m thinking we need to go lay down the ground rules. And we’re going to need something stronger than cinnamon rolls and pie for that.”
“This is so much better,” I say as I take a healthy drink of the beer I ordered. “I’m sorry I didn’t think about not going over all of that in front of people we know.”
“No need to apologize,” Sutton says as she stirs her cocktail. I don’t know what it is, but it’s yellow and red and has about eighteen cherries in it. “Honestly, I was more worried about Kitty and Phyllis overhearing. Yes, they were on the other side of the bakery, but I also feel like they could’ve bugged our booth somehow.”
“They’re a pair,” I say. “The first time I met them they each pinched my ass. Same time. Each took a cheek. I jumped so high I almost hit the ceiling.”
Sutton nearly spits out her drink. “Question for you. Who’d you rather have grabbing your ass? Phyllis, Kitty, or Erika?”
That’s an awful question. “I have to pick between those three?”
“Yes, and none of the above isn’t an option.”
I only need a second to think about my answer. “Phyllis. She has a little bit more arthritis in her hands, so the pinches aren’t as hard.”
Sutton laughs at my joke, which has me feeling…good. It’s been a while since I made anyone laugh. Or since someone’s made me laugh. Or smile. Adalyn and the occasional baffoonery of my teammates don’t count. Neither does Theo, Beau, or Maddox. But seeing a genuinely happy reaction from Sutton? Well…it has me feeling some sort of way that I don’t know how to process right now.
“Well, I’ll have to watch out for them if I’m about to be your girlfriend. Hands off my man and all that jazz.”
I know she’s trying to lighten the situation, and I appreciate it, but I can’t figure out a better segue than this question. “You’re seriously willing to do this?”
She nods and sits up a little straighter on her side of the booth. “I admit, at first I thought you were a little cuckoo. But somewhere between me not blinking and wondering if I had a hearing problem, I realized that if you’re asking me to do this, you have to have a good reason. And like I said, having a boyfriend right now helps me too.”