Page 20 of Unlikely Pair

Page List

Font Size:

That’s not a lie. I’m off tonight, as is Theo. Beau—a professional golfer who has control of his schedule—isn’t playing this weekend, and Maddox doesn’t start football training camp for another few months.

“Why not?” Beau mimics. “For all the years I’ve known you, and all the nights we’ve baked together, I don’t think I’ve ever heard the words ‘why not’ leave your mouth.”

I turn on the stand mixer to start combining my wet ingredients. “You’re being dramatic.”

“No, he’s not,” Theo says. “As our resident Poker Club historian, I know not once in our tenure have you ever instigated a meeting. Let alone a surprise one.”

I narrow my eyes at Theo. “Historian? Have you been taking minutes?”

He taps his brain. “It’s all up here, my friend. Now talk. What’s going on and why are we baking on a Thursday?”

When the three of us started Poker Club, it was meant for a place we could go to get away. The bonus that came with it is the camaraderie with others who know the pressures of your job. Someone you can talk to who understands the life you live. Yes, we’ve always talked about personal things, but when Maddox came along—which coincided with Gabi being pregnant—I feel like the personal talk went up a level.

We helped Maddox navigate Gabi’s pregnancy and the first months of his son’s life. We helped Beau realize he didn’t hate his wife as much as he thought he did—before and during their marriage.

As for Theo, our happy-go-lucky guy of the group, most of our life advice centers around trying to convince him he’s in love with his best friend, Ellie. We’re not there yet, but one day, we’re going to make him see he’s head-over-heels for her.

Luckily for me, the guys have always stayed out of my personal life. They know it's hard for me to talk about Hailey, so they give me the space to talk when I need to without pushing me too hard. Except, as I’m looking at the three sets of eyes staring at me now, I don’t think that’s going to continue.

And I don’t want it to, at least not tonight. No, tonight I need verification that I’m right and my teammates are annoying assholes.

“Can I ask you guys a question?”

Theo sets down his spatula and turns all of his attention to me. “We’ve been waiting for that question for years.”

“Settle down or I won’t ask it.”

He holds his hands up in surrender. “Apologies. Proceed.”

I take a breath, not really sure if I should be bringing this up. Except, if I don’t, it’s going to eat away at me like it has been the past day and a half. “Do you guys think I should be trying to date?”

The room falls silent save for the whir of the exhaust fan, the hum of the ovens, and the thud of Beau dropping his ball of dough in shock.

“Are…are you…” Maddox takes a second to spit out whatever it is he’s trying to say. “Are you dating?”

“Of course not,” I say quickly.

“Then why are you asking?” Theo chimes in.

“Are you guys going to answer or not?”

I didn’t think this was a hard question, but apparently with personal questions also come fifteen subsequent questions that are annoying me more than the initial question.

“Sorry Asher,” Beau begins. “But this is the first personal question you’ve ever asked us without prompting, and you started with that one?”

“Is it that hard of a question?”

“No, but I feel like we need context,” Theo says. “How about you tell us where this is coming from, because I feel like that’s important to this situation.”

“Fine. It’s coming because of my fucking teammates,” I begin, filling them in on Finn and Liam’s antics. “And it’s not just because they want to include me in the steak dinners. That’s just the beginning part of their plan. First we go get something to eat and then, ‘oh! Look at that! We ended up at a bar! With women!’ They think I need to get laid, which I don’t. Even the guys who have wives or girlfriends have been on my ass. But I don’t need to date. I’m fine. And they don’t believe me.”

“So just tell them that?” Maddox says. “Say thanks but no thanks.”

“I do,” I say, turning off my mixer. I can’t multitask adding my dry ingredients while getting all of this off my chest. “And it’s been working, but lately…I don’t know. It feels like it’s part of every conversation. Last night they tried to guilt me into it by saying we needed to celebrate the win. It was a game three win in the second round of the playoffs. It’s not like we clinched the cup. I told them to fuck off and I went home.”

“It’s a free country, you do what you want,” Beau says. “But, before I give you the advice I think you’re asking for, I need to make sure of one thing. Are you mad that they won’t take no for an answer, or mad at the question in the first place?”

“The question,” I answer without hesitation. “Because if they would stop asking, I wouldn’t have to keep telling them no.”


Novels you may like ...