Page 176 of Unlikely Pair

Page List

Font Size:

“You can tell yourself that, but we know it’s a lie,” Maddox offers. “You swing at pitches every day that you don’t know if you’re going to hit. Why won’t you try with Ellie?”

Theo looks at him, and for the first time since we’ve known him, I think he’s actually going to admit his feelings. “Because I can’t lose her.”

“I get that,” I say, patting him on the back. “And it’s easier to keep her as a friend than to risk shooting the shot. But you know who she’s marrying, right? The asshole who Sutton told me is ordering her how to wear her hair for their wedding. The guy who was going to bitch about how much her haircut cost. Is that who you want her to marry?”

I don’t know what in our speeches turns on the lightbulb over his head, but something does. In the blink of an eye, he’s gone from depressed and down to the determined guy we see on the field every day, always ready to push the limits while trying to reach another base.

No, it’s more than that—this is the guy who’s about to get the girl.

“I’ve got to go,” Theo says quickly, all but sprinting through my backyard toward the gate, slamming it behind him, leaving all of us shaking our heads and smiling in his cloud of dust.

“What just happened there?” Sutton asks as she walks over to us. “Is Theo okay?”

“I sure as hell hope so,” Beau says, giving Sutton a kiss on the cheek before walking back toward Shelby, who he left in charge at the grill. Maddox follows, leaving us here together, under the biggest tree in my backyard, and a little bit away from the crowd gathered.

“How is everything?” I ask as I bring her into my arms.

“People are eating. Kids are having a good time. And your mom is rounding up people for a poker game later.”

“Of course she is.”

I lean in to sneak a kiss from Sutton, feeling like this is the first time we’ve been actually alone today. But, like they usually do, two tiny voices cut through the air.

“Daddy!”

“Mama!”

Adalyn and Maverick come racing over to us, both of them still dripping from the swimming pool, getting both of us wet as they jump into our arms.

“Did you dry off at all?” I tease, wiping the water from her ponytail off my face.

“Kinda,” she says. “Can everyone stay late tonight so we can go night swimming and watch a movie at the pool?”

“Puh-leeeeeessseee?” Maddox jumps in, adding a puppy lip for good measure.

“Who’s everyone?” I ask, even though I already know I’m going to say yes.

“All the kids. And the parents. And Uncle Maddox. He said he’s never seen Shrek.”

“Can we watch Shrek, Asher? It’ll be so fun at the pool!”

I don’t know what prompted me to buy a projector to watch outdoor movies this summer. Oh wait, yes I do. Sutton mentioned it would be fun, and the next day I was adding it to my cart for two-day shipping.

I’m down bad, as the kids say. And I don’t even care.

Because I love this woman. And I love the life and family we’ve brought together.

“I don’t know,” I say, dragging this out. “What do you think, babe? Movie night by the pool?”

My smile gives away that I’m going to say yes, which earns me one in return that hits me right in the chest. It’s full of love. A realization that this is our life. And how a few random run-ins and a ridiculous idea led to the life we’re building here. Together.

“I think a movie night sounds great,” Sutton says.

The shriek from the kids is deafening as wet arms wrap each of us around the neck in a big hug.

“Thank you, Daddy,” Adalyn says as she gives me a big, wet kiss on my cheek. “This is the best day ever.”

I reach out for Sutton’s hand, pulling her and Maverick in so I can wrap everyone I care about into one big hug. “Yes it is, Peanut. Yes it is.”


Novels you may like ...