She hops off the chair, giving Sutton a huge hug. “Thank you for braiding my hair. And for teaching Daddy.”
Tears well in my eyes before I know they’re coming.
“You’re welcome, sweetheart. It was my honor.”
I turn away from the interaction and go stand by the sink. Sutton tells Maverick to use the restroom before we leave, but I don’t turn to see anything else. I just close my eyes, trying to pull the tears back.
It’s no use, so I open them and stare out the window, my mind going to a place it often goes during moments like this.
See that Hailey? After all these years, I finally learned to do it. Aren’t you proud of me?
“You okay?”
I jump a little, not realizing Sutton moved up behind me. “Yeah? Why wouldn’t I be?”
“I don’t know, you just…spaced out for a second. You were smiling, but just staring off to the unknown. Also, I can see you’re crying. You aren’t as tough as you think, Reed.”
I know Sutton’s trying to lighten the situation, but it’s probably time I let her in on my secret. “Can I tell you something? Something I do that I know isn’t normal, but it’s something I think you should know.”
“Okay…”
Way to make it sound ominous, Reed.
“Sometimes I talk to Hailey.”
I’ve been scared to tell this to Sutton. Even though she’s been nothing but amazing knowing my past, admitting you talk to your dead wife could, and probably should, freak someone out.
But not Sutton.
She takes my hand, pulls me toward two seats at the island, and gives me a look reassuring me she’s here for me, and wants to hear everything I have to say.
“I don’t do it in an ‘I think she’s a ghost’ kind of way. Just, sometimes when things happen that I wish she could see, or something that Adalyn says that’s funny, or when I need to give myself permission to ask a woman to be my fake, and real, girlfriend, I talk to her. It’s like she’s become my internal monologue at times.”
“What did you just tell her?”
“That I finally learned to do Adalyn’s hair.”
“Would she have thought that was a big deal?”
I love how interested she is, like she truly wants to know who Hailey was. “Silly enough, it was one of my biggest worries when we found out we were having a girl. That and how to keep her away from romantic partners until she turned forty.”
Sutton laughs and takes hold of my hands. “I love that you do that.”
“You do?”
“Yes. She’s always going to be part of your life, Asher. She was your first love. The mother of your child. I know I wouldn’t be here if circumstances were different, and I can’t be mad about that. Or jealous. She’s a part of you. She’s a part of Adalyn. I never want you to stop talking about her. Or remembering her. And if you do, I’ll start talking to her and the two of us will decide how to kick your ass.”
I laugh through the happy tears as I bring Sutton’s and my lips together. “I love you, Sutton. You and Maverick. I didn’t plan on it. I tried to talk myself out of it. I even convinced myself we could be casual. I was wrong on all of it. But you are my family, Sutton. You and Maverick. Me and Adalyn. A modern day Brady Bunch with a weird side plot of an aunt stepmom and a meddling grandmother who serves as the comic relief.”
Sutton laughs at my joke. “For years, I never knew if I’d have a family. I knew mine wasn’t normal. I knew I was the only kid in my class whose mom had different husbands and boyfriends yearly. I knew I wasn’t supposed to be cooking dinner or doing laundry just because I was the oldest daughter. And then, when adult me thought I’d formed the family I chose, the family of blood came and tore it apart.
“Honestly, Asher, I gave up on having any semblance of family. And then you came along. You with your slight smile and Adalyn and her messed up bangs. You two had me by the heartstrings the second I met you. I love you, Asher Reed, and this family we’re making.”
I lean in, taking her chin in my fingertips. “I love you, Sutton Walker. So much.”
Our kiss is gentle. No tongue. No urgency. No need to see if we have time to slip into our now favorite hall closet. Just Sutton and me, sealing this bond we have.
Love. Family.