Growing up, our teachers taught us about the nature versus nurture debate. But with the life I’ve lived, I call bullcrap on both. Because Angelina and I were raised by the same woman and we couldn’t have turned out more different. And since both of us had barely-present fathers, I doubt their five seconds of contribution to creating us had anything to do with how we turned out.
I’m the people pleaser. Angelina just cares about pleasing herself. Or whatever man she’s with.
I’m the one who thinks before she speaks or acts. Angelina barely thinks, let alone cares about how her actions will affect others.
I was the one who made sure we had things to eat when mom was out trying to find her next husband. Angelina was the one who expected food to show up on her plate, and never said thank you.
I’m the one who worked hard to make sure I’m the furthest thing from my mother as possible. Angelina decided to become her carbon copy.
This reaction is a classic example of why we’re only sisters by relation. Because since the day I found out about her and Rob, this has been how she acts. Fake nice. Pretending everything is okay. “Not understanding” why I’m upset about the fact her now fiancé was at the time my live-in boyfriend and is the father of my child.
Add on my mother’s mirrored reaction, and I realize now I’m really going to have to fight through this conversation to guarantee we don’t end things in World War III. Because that’s what I do, keep the peace. Put a smile on my face and pretend everything’s okay. Don’t ruffle feathers. Play the dutiful role of the eldest daughter by doing what needs to be done and never complaining a day.
I really wish this place served liquor…
“Apparently he does,” I grit out. “It’s just when we were together, he wasn’t interested in marriage. So this caught me off guard.”
That’s the nicest way I can put that while still being honest. Rob and I talked about marriage often, and it always ended the same way—he wasn’t interested. He said he didn’t believe in it. Not when I brought it up after we moved in together. Not when we talked about it after I found out I was pregnant. Every time I even hinted at marriage during the three years-plus we were together, he dismissed it faster than he sends pucks across the ice.
Yet two years with my sister and it seems he’s ready to walk down the aisle. Either she really is the true love of his life or there’s something more to this story.
I’m going with the latter.
“Men can change their minds, Sutton,” Mom says as she waves over Gabi. “In my experience, they do it all the time…”
And oh the experience she has…
My mother subscribes to the motto “you are nothing without a man,” and my sister has been her prized student since she could walk. Angelina doesn’t have the history my mother does yet, but even in several years that would still be a hard hurdle to clear. I believe the current tally of Barbara “Babs” McCarthy’s all-time roster is five husbands, five divorces, four other fiancés, and an unknown number of “gentlemen suitors” who have come cycling through the house over the years.
Although…Angelina getting married at twenty-two does put her on the right timeline to match—or maybe beat—my mother’s record of weddings and divorces.
“You’re right, Mom. People do change their minds.” Maybe if I’m nice and pleasant, and a little extra patient, I’ll get the real story behind why he changed his mind. “So Angelina, how did he propose?”
My sister lights up, forgetting just seconds before she was trying to cut me down. “Sutton, I wasn’t expecting it at all!”
“Tell me all about it,” I encourage her, leaning in like I’m getting girl talk, or, as the younger assistants around the salon say, the tea. “Every detail. Don’t leave out a thing.”
My sister has never been great at picking up when I’m being fake or sarcastic. That little feature is serving me well right now. Makes it easier to feign excitement about wanting to know what happened, when what I really want is to figure out why Rob caved in on marriage.
“Rob was at practice, you know how he’s never home during playoffs, so I was taking the time to clean our bedroom. I know how much he likes a clean house.”
It takes everything in me not to roll my eyes. Because yes, I do know how much he likes a clean house. I also know he won’t lift a finger to do it, and if Angelina is doing it, that’s probably why he’s marrying her. If he has a wife, he can get rid of the housekeeper.
“Anyway, I was putting away his laundry, and I just happened to stumble upon a ring in his underwear drawer. Just sitting there for anyone to see!”
Translation: She was snooping. It was not there to see. Boundaries and Angelina have never met.
“Did you tell him about it?” I ask. “Or did you keep it a secret?”
“I mean, I wanted to keep it a secret, but I was just too excited! Because what do you mean he was going to ask me to marry him?”
I swallow my “he wasn’t” reaction, opting instead for a leading, “So what did you do?”
“Well, when he got home, I dropped all of the hints I could about weddings. I changed into an all white set from a cute little boutique downtown, found a bridal magazine I happened to grab at the store last week, and was casually flipping through it when he got home. And the icing on the cake? I was watching one of those reality wedding shows when he walked in the door.”
“Sly…”
“Right!”