I look to my left, and Asher doesn't even have his eyes on the road. No, he's looking at me, begging me to confide in him.
“I hate that I’m even mad about this,” I begin. “But every time I think I’ve learned everything Rob lied about, or every way he kept me separate from his hockey life, I learn about something else. I don't want to be angry about it. And I'm not angry because I want him back, or because I want to hold this against him in some way, it's just…”
I try to find my words, but this time, it’s Asher’s turn to complete my thought. “You didn’t think he could hurt you anymore. And yet, he’s still finding ways to.”
“Exactly,” I say with a breath of relief. “I hate that I believed the lies me told me. I was a stupid girl with hearts in her eyes who thought she’d found her forever.”
“And he’s charming,” Asher adds. “I know he’s a dick, but I’ve seen him pour on the charm when he needs to.”
“And I fell for it hook, line, and sinker. He swept me off my feet. He sent me flowers. Took me out on the town. Gave me hockey tickets so I could come watch his games. Well, they were nosebleeds. And it only happened twice. But I was young and dumb and dating a hockey player. I was completely under his spell.”
“You don’t have to answer this if you don’t want to, but were there times before you found him with Angelina that you saw red flags?”
I don’t mean to bark out a laugh, but I can’t help it. “At the very beginning. When I found out I was the other woman.”
He shakes his head in disbelief. “How many relationships did my teammate have that none of us knew about?”
“I have a feeling that number will never be known. When I found out I was the other woman, I felt horrible. I even tried to break up with him. But again, naive twenty-four-year-old me believed his crap. You know the one. The old ‘he was already trying to break up with her and he wanted to be with me.’ I just needed to give him two months, just until the season was over, and he promised he’d end it. And he did. I thought we were good.”
I take a second and reflect on all the red flags I ignored, and all the times I made excuses for his questionable behavior. Times on the road when he wouldn’t answer a call or text message, always blaming team meetings or practices. Vague answers on why he didn’t come home some nights until the early hours of the next morning.
Dinners he’d go to with his teammates that he said were only for players.
“I know it’s not my job to apologize for him, Sutton, but I’m so sorry,” Asher says. “If I knew what he was doing for all those years, believe me, a bunch of us would’ve set him straight.”
Asher takes back my hand, bringing it to his lips for a lingering kiss. "I hate that he hurt you in the past. That he’s hurting you now. It makes me want to put his head through a wall," Asher says. "Please know, he's never going to hurt you from here on out. When it comes to you and Maverick, if I have my way, he's never gonna hurt either of you again."
I don't know how Asher can hold that promise, but I know my heart is already clinging to it like a lifeline.
We pull into the parking garage downtown, and the moment he shifts into park, I take his face in my hands, bringing him in for a kiss I need to give him more than anything right now.
"Thank you," I say. “For everything. But especially for bringing me here tonight.”
“You’re welcome,” he says, kissing my forehead. “I guess it's time I tell you the good news.”
“Good news?”
His smile is a little conniving. I like it. “You might not have known this team as long as you possibly could. And you’ve only met this crew a handful of times. But I need you to know when you walk into this dinner tonight, everyone in that room who wears a Rockers jersey, and their significant others, like you better than him.”
That makes me laugh. “Honestly? That might be the best revenge.”
“Just wait until I kiss you in front of him again,” Asher says, leaning in for a preview. “It’s going to drive him crazy. And I’m going to fucking love every minute of it.”
I didn’t get into this bogus relationship to make Rob’s teammates like me more than him.
This is just an added bonus.
“Sutton, has Asher told you about the time he learned about credit card roulette?”
I laugh as I turn to Asher, who’s glaring at Liam across the table. “Why no, Liam. He hasn’t told me that story.”
“I’m surprised he hasn’t. He’s still paying off the bill.”
“I still think it was rigged,” Asher says, a joking tone to his voice.
He also takes that opportunity to put his arm around my shoulder. Not mad about that one.
“When was this?” All eyes turn to Rob, who seems confused about the story. “How did I miss a night when Reed paid?”