My reply is half word, half sigh. “Yeah.”
“Why did you say yes to being in her wedding? No one would fault you from staying real fucking clear from them.”
“I know, it’s just…”
I don’t quite know how to articulate this without sounding pathetic. Then I feel Asher take my hand in his, and suddenly I have the little bit of courage I need to say the words out loud.
“When we were growing up, Mom wasn’t around much. Angelina would never admit it, but I basically raised her.”
“You’re not that much older than her.”
“You’d be amazed the things a twelve-year-old can figure out when you have to teach yourself how to cook dinners,” I say. “But it was me and her. We were close. We stayed up late watching television and then pretended to sleep when Mom got home from a date. I gave Angelina every haircut she had until high school. We taught ourselves how to sew, and my denim jacket decorating skills came from crafts we did together.”
“Sounds like you guys made the best of the situation.”
“We did. At least I thought we did,” I say. “When I think of Angelina, somewhere in my brain I still see the little girl who would come sleep with me when she had a bad dream. The one who came to me, not our mom, when she got her period for the first time. The girl who used to not look at me like I was crud at the bottom of her shoe.”
“You see your sister.”
I nod against his chest. “That’s who I need to see. When I stand next to her at the altar, it’s not going to be next to the woman who ended what I thought was my forever. I’m standing next to the little girl I’m holding onto. That memory. The girl with pigtails who used to love me.”
I don’t want to cry, but I don’t think avoiding that is possible.
Before a tear can slip down my cheek, Asher has turned me to him, wiping it away with his thumb. “I’m so sorry, Sutton,” he says as he holds me. “I’m so fucking sorry.”
“I know I seem foolish doing all of this. Helping plan her wedding. Wearing an expensive dress I don’t want to wear and couldn’t really afford. Even going to the wedding, especially knowing that when all is said and done, Angelina and Rob are apparently going to be out of Maverick’s, and my, life for good. But for some reason, I just couldn’t say no. For some reason, I still want their approval. Or love. Maybe both.”
“It’s hard to turn that off,” Asher says. “No matter what ‘that’ is for anyone, letting go is hard. I know that better than anyone.”
I stiffen in his hold, suddenly feeling guilty for the position I’m in. But when I try to pull away, Asher doesn’t let me. He keeps hold of me. Not only that, he holds me tighter.
“I didn’t say that to make you feel bad, just that I understand how you could want to hold onto something you know isn’t there. And it’s hard hurdling that feat. Whatever it may be.”
“Was it hard tonight?” I ask softly, needing to know how he’s feeling about what happened, and is happening, between us. Because it’s something. And the last thing I want to do in this situation is assume.
“Surprisingly no,” he says, and while I can’t see him, I can envision his small smile just by the inflection of his voice. “Kissing you was easy, Sutton. Too easy.”
“Too easy?”
“Every time I’ve thought about dating, my mind came up with every excuse for why I wasn’t ready. But at the end of the day, they all came down to the fact that I was just scared to take the leap.”
“So tonight? You just jumped?”
“Head first without a parachute.”
His slight smile is back, and I don’t know what kryptonite he has in it, but every time I see it, I melt a little inside.
“You didn’t seem to break any bones?”
“As far as I’m concerned, I’m still in midair.” He pauses for a second, taking a deep breath. I give each of his hands a squeeze, hoping he knows he can take as long as he wants. “Sutton…I know this started as fake. As a way for both of us to serve a purpose we needed. But now…I…I…I’m not…it’s…”
I don’t know where this thought is coming from, but Asher says I have a way of reading his mind. And I don’t know if this is what he’s thinking, but I have a feeling my idea is going to be a solution he either hasn’t thought of, or is unwilling to ask for.
“How about I help you out with this,” I say, tipping his chin up so we can be eye to eye. “I don’t want to actually date you.”
His eyes go wide, and he starts to speak, but I put my finger over his lips so I can finish my thought.
“But I want to kiss you again.”