Page 101 of Unlikely Pair

Page List

Font Size:

“Because…” Finn takes over, full dramatics in action. “As you’ve said, ‘Why should I be uncomfortable to just fucking drive home. I already hate I have to dress up to get here.’”

I did say all of that. Damn my words—that I still totally believe—coming back to bite me in the ass.

“If you must know, Sutton and I are going out for dinner.”

“Ooooooooohhhhhhhh.”

I swear my teammates are ten-year-old girls.

“We’re dating. It’s dinner. It’s nothing to get all worked up about.”

I really shouldn’t have said that as I put cologne on.

“We’re not worked up,” Liam says. “We’re just…”

“Happy for you.”

“Yes. What Finn said. We’re happy for you.”

I turn around, putting the cologne on the top shelf of my locker before I grab my bag. “Thanks. Now, can I leave? I don’t want to keep Sutton waiting.”

The two of them step to either side of me, extending their arms as if I’m about to walk down a red carpet.

All I can do is shake my head as I walk past them. “See you both tomorrow.”

“We want deets,” Finn yells.

“And don’t do anything I wouldn’t.”

I laugh at Liam. That doesn’t leave much on the table.

I make my way down the hallway lined with past team pictures before turning the corner toward the exit leading to the area where families wait for players. My heart rate goes up a bit, a mixture of nerves and a little guilt as I think about who’s waiting for me on the other side. Hailey used to wait for me before Adalyn was born. When Mom brings Adalyn to a game, they’ll wait for me here. But there’s something about the thought of seeing Sutton that’s hitting me out of nowhere.

It’s not real. This is for show. This is to get the guys off your back. To help Sutton. Her being here is just part of that ruse.

I forget every one of those words as I push the door open and see Sutton barreling toward me, jumping in my arms.

“Well hi there,” I say, catching her just in time.

“I hope this is okay. But I thought it would be weird if I didn’t hug you in front of your friends and your teammates. And then I saw my sister, who has never come to a game, and I knew I really needed to sell this because I don’t think she believes I’m bringing you to the wedding. I’m sorry if it’s too much.”

“No, it’s good,” I say, trying to calm my breath.

And it is good. Maybe too good. The angle she’s in leaves her neck right at my nose, and I can’t help but get swept away by the smell of her perfume. Has she always worn this? I didn’t notice it when we went ice skating. Then again, I was so nervous about eighteen different parts of that night, I could’ve not realized it. But I am now. It’s warm. Vanilla with some hints of florals. Perfectly Sutton.

“Get a room, you two!”

I laugh as I hear Finn’s voice from behind me, and, shit, this hug might’ve been a little too long. I slowly lower Sutton to the ground, and it’s the first time I truly get a look at her.

Her red hair is down and curled, the waves sitting across her shoulders. I know if she turns around I’d see my name and number on the back of her denim jacket—one my teammates have told me their wives and girlfriends are dying to get for themselves. She’s paired it with a white fitted shirt and black pants that are so tight I have no issue imagining the curves of her hips.

Simply? She looks gorgeous. And if this were real, she’d look like she’s mine.

“Hey? You okay?” Sutton asks, putting her hand to my cheek. “You look a little flushed?”

“Yeah. I’m good,” I say, shaking my head to get it back on right. “You ready to go?”

She nods her head, giving me another one of those smiles that always makes me feel like everything’s going to be okay. I take her hand in mine, lacing our fingers together as we make our way toward the player parking lot. A few people give us a wave, and Sutton is all smiles back as I do my best to acknowledge them with the hand that’s holding my duffel bag.


Novels you may like ...