Page 63 of Hard No

Page List

Font Size:

She didn’t mention the murder part. All she said was, “Knox will take care of it. Don’t worry.”

“I know he will,” I hissed back, then clamped my lips shut. It was the truth, I realized. Somewhere along the way, I decided I trusted Knox implicitly to help me handle Enzo and his cronies. Not just with Enzo, either. I trusted Knox with my body. With my safety.

Did I trust him with my heart?

I blinked over to look at his profile, catching him glaring at the closed folder.

And my heart sank.

Inside that folder was his perfect match. Someone who had applied to marry him, who was ready to move to this town with a whole lot less baggage than I had. Knox and I had chemistry, sure, but what else did we have? Animosity. Years of dislike. A few sparks that had finally caught flame last night.

He would be better off with whoever was in that folder.

“And after Knox has taken care of your problem,” Etta continued, “he’ll marry his future bride.”

A sick mix of yearning and bitterness swirled in my belly as Etta pushed herself to her feet. She left her half-finished coffee on the table and turned to Knox, who had stood up at the same time as her. He bent almost in half so she could put her hands on his shoulders, kissing each of his cheeks in turn.

“I love you,” she told him, “and I’m so proud of you.”

Knox watched her as she gathered her purse and her scarf. He opened the door for her, but Etta paused in the opening and turned to look at me. “I take it the family-wide ban is now lifted at Knead More Bread? I do love your rye loaves.”

“Doesn’t seem like my ban was very effective in the first place,” I deadpanned.

Etta gave me a dagger-sharp smile. “Goodbye, Caroline. Knox. I’ll see you both on Sunday.”

The door closed behind her, and I glared at Knox. “Why is everyone assuming I’ll be at your family meal this weekend?”

Knox tore his gaze from the folder on the table to look at me. “What’s going on between us, Caroline?”

I reared back. “You want to talk about this now? Don’t you think there are more important things going on?”

“I don’t want to spend another five years fighting with you, thinking I’ve got a chance at keeping you. If that’s not what you want, just put me out of my misery.”

His words were everything I wanted to believe but couldn’t. Even after everything—all the years of animosity, the thrown donuts, the hurled insults—he would really choose me? When he knew what I’d done? Who I was?

I opened my mouth, but nothing came out. He wanted me to promise forever—or at least promise for now. How could I? It wasn’t just Enzo stopping me from doing it. It was me. It was the big, fat secret I still hadn’t fessed up to. The thing that would break Knox if he found out. When he found out.

I couldn’t promise him forever, or even for now. We were on borrowed time already.

“What is this, Caroline? You and me?”

My chest ached, like a giant was trying to pry my ribs open. I swallowed once, twice, and finally scratched out, “Maybe we’re just letting off steam with everything that’s going on. Maybe once Enzo is dealt with, whatever’s going on between us will end.”

The tightness around his eyes became more pronounced. He stared at me for a beat, then dipped his chin. “Maybe,” he said. “I’m going to take a shower.”

He stalked out, and I sat there, feeling numb. When the shower turned on, I stopped resisting temptation, and I pulled the folder toward me. I opened it up and was confronted with a picture of a beautiful brunette with big doe eyes. She had a pageant-queen smile complete with two perfect dimples. My eyes scanned the sheet. Greta Higgins. Graduated from Harvard Law. Worked at a nonprofit helping people on Death Row overturn wrongful convictions using advances in DNA technology. Volunteered at an animal shelter. Loved deep and meaningful conversation, but wasn’t opposed to vegging on the couch watching football with the man she loved. Loved to cook. Her signature dish was a steak sandwich with homemade tomato relish.

There was nothing in there about enjoying antagonizing big, burly men who knew too much. Nothing about target practice with donuts. Nothing about being too grumpy, too scared, too unworthy to end up with the one person she realized she really wanted.

Greta Higgins had probably never killed a man. No—she saved them from execution instead.

I closed the folder and pushed it back across the table, feeling small and sad. Knox would get bored of me and end up with her. He’d realize that deep down inside, I just wasn’t worth saving.

KNOX

Water pelted over my body as I tried to calm the roiling storm in my chest.

Caroline was it for me. I knew that—maybe I’d known it for four and a half years, because why else had I kept coming back to her, day after day after day?


Novels you may like ...