Page 51 of Hard No

Page List

Font Size:

I leaned forward to grab my mug from the coffee table and let my mind spin while I took a sip. Then I set it down and exhaled.

I had no choice. I had to tell him.

“It was Tony’s. Or at least, it had been given to him to get rid of. Lanie found it that night, and that’s why they got in a fight. I guess she never realized how serious they were. The Family.” It had to be capitalized when I said it like that: it wasn’t just the Costa family. They were an organization.

Knox sipped his coffee, saying nothing.

I knew that safety lay in silence. Before I’d come to Marswood Harbor, I’d had to run and run and run. The minute I let anything slip about myself, I’d had to leave wherever I’d landed. The Costa Family’s tentacles were long and numerous. I’d gotten used to telling people nothing about myself, my past, and my secrets.

Now I sat across from a man who’d held information over my head for four and a half years. I should’ve been terrified about telling him anything. But try as I might, I couldn’t stop myself from feeling safe with him. I wanted to tell him the whole story. I wanted to be honest with him in a way I hadn’t been in a long, long time. Maybe ever.

But what would happen when I did? When he knew every awful detail? When he could see all the dark parts of me?

I tucked my hair behind my ear and fought with myself. My head told me to tell him as little as possible. Make Bennett’s cake (or donuts, or whatever medieval peasant fare Marnie decided she wanted) and let Knox take care of Enzo. Go back to my small, quiet life and try to pretend none of this ever happened.

My heart told me I was a fool. There was no coming back from this.

“So it was used in a crime,” Knox prodded.

“I think so. Yes.”

“Do you know which crime?”

My mouth went dry. “There was talk, you know, around that time…”

Knox waited patiently while I gathered the words.

There was no getting out of this, was there? “Tony Costa Sr. is facing racketeering charges right now. I think… I think he might have committed a murder of a man who tried to stab him in the back, and then he asked his son to get rid of the gun.”

“But Tony Jr. never did get rid of it.”

“No,” I agreed, mulling that over. Had he been keeping it as leverage? Had Lanie threatened his plans? I would never know.

“Why do you have the gun, Caroline?” Knox’s voice was gentle, and it was that softness that tipped the balance toward my heart. I would tell him whatever he needed to know, because I wanted to trust him. As foolish as that might be.

I blinked up to look at him, sighed, and said, “I don’t know. I guess I figured I could use it, if it came down to it. But it also freaks me out, and I didn’t want to throw it out somewhere another person would find it and use it for something bad. So then I hid it. And it just kind of…stayed there.”

“In the cookie jar.”

I glared at him. “In my defense, you’re the only person who’s looked in my cookie jar.” He was the only person who’d been in my apartment other than me, a plumber, and an electrician, but still.

There was a long silence. I tried to still my thoughts, to not let myself spin out. Would Knox go to the police? Get me arrested for having the gun? Throw me out of his house? Renege on our agreement and tell me I was on my own?

Knox took a deep breath and dipped his chin. “All right.”

“All right? What does that mean?”

“It means, fine. We have an illegal gun. We have a vindictive asshole on our tail. We have options.”

“I didn’t actually hear any options in that list,” I noted.

He gave me a slash of a smile, like he thought I was adorable. Which was annoying.

“Maybe I should buy some bullets,” I said, not really meaning it.

“No.” His tone was final.

“I could get one of those cute little revolvers that fit in a purse.”


Novels you may like ...