There were cops to talk to, reports to make, and about a hundred surfaces to clean up. I told the deputy everything he wanted to know; there was no reason to hide anymore. I could tell he didn’t know what to make of my story. He mumbled something about calling the feds, and I just shrugged in response. I was simply tired: tired of hiding, tired of running, tired of having people attack me in my own damn home. It all took forever. I sent Marnie home with boxed-up cake samples and a promise to make her some fresh donuts another day. Bennett stayed to help with the chaos.
Knox was always nearby, his presence strong and steady.
Finally, hours later, everyone was gone. Everyone except Knox, who hovered near me while pretending he wasn’t hovering. I shuffled out to the front of the bakery, intending to put the chairs up on top of the tables so I could mop, but I ended up sinking into one of them instead. Knox pulled a chair out across from me and leaned back.
We stared at each other, and a warm glow began to pulse in the middle of my chest. Through all the chaos that had happened today, Knox had been by my side. He’d filled my water bottle and coaxed me to eat something, then fielded questions from the deputies when I’d been wavering on my feet.
He’d been…kind. Just like those very first days we’d had together.
But this softening toward him felt dangerous in a way Enzo wasn’t. It threatened the very core of me, and I couldn’t allow myself any more vulnerability. So as he watched me steadily, I pursed my lips and said, “This cake-for-protection deal is turning out to be a nightmare.”
“Oh?”
“Yeah. Making a wedding cake for that woman is way more work than you sitting here looking at security footage and then coming in when the fight is over to take all the credit.”
His laugh was a low rumble that warmed me to my toes. Then a sigh slipped through his lips as he rubbed the bridge of his nose, looking suddenly exhausted. He shifted, rubbing his fingers against his scalp and mussing his hair. The glasses had left two indents on either side of his nose, and I noticed lines of exhaustion around his eyes and mouth.
When he looked at me, it was with aching remorse. “I should have been in that kitchen with you today. I’m sorry you had to fight him off on your own. If you’d gotten hurt…”
My heart squeezed at his words, and I didn’t want to acknowledge why. Didn’t want to think about the fact that Knox would be bothered by my being hurt. That he might actually care. Instead, I changed the subject. “Can I ask you something?”
“Sure.”
“You found out about Tony within days of meeting me.” I tilted my head as he watched me silently. Gulping, I continued. “You knew I’d killed a man. You told me you knew I’d killed a man. You told me this was your town, and you wouldn’t tolerate trouble. Why didn’t you make me leave?”
Knox watched me, and I wondered what he remembered about those days. I wondered if he could tell I was on the edge of panic all the time. If he had seen the lack of sleep in my face the way I could see it in his right now.
I wondered if, like me, he’d spent four and a half years replaying that moment in the bakery kitchen, wondering what would have happened if I hadn’t pushed him away.
“I didn’t want you to leave,” he finally replied.
I frowned. “Why not? You must have known I’d cause trouble eventually.”
His lips tipped up at the corners. “Babe, you caused trouble from the moment you arrived.”
I straightened, offended. “How?”
“Buying this place up out from under my grandmother’s nose, for starters.”
“She owns half of Main Street! And if Beryl hadn’t wanted me to have this place, she wouldn’t have let me buy it.”
Knox chuckled, shrugging. “Grandma likes control.”
I popped a brow, waving a hand in his direction. “Apple, tree.”
His grin widened. “I don’t like control. I like information.”
“Information is control, Knox.”
He tilted his head, reluctantly agreeing. “Maybe it would be more accurate to say that I hate secrets.”
My heart gave a violent thump. He knew my biggest, darkest secret. He knew I was a killer. But he didn’t know the other half of it—the reason I’d come here, to Marswood Harbor. The reason I’d chosen this town specifically to disappear. I gulped, my throat tight. “How come?”
He watched me with those ocean eyes, assessing. Deciding whether I was worthy of his secret. Then, very simply, he shrugged and said, “I guess it started with my mom.”
That wasn’t what I had expected. My stomach went hollow, and my mind tried to tell me to stop this conversation before it went any further. Keep my distance. Stick to the cake-for-protection deal. Stop the runaway train that was this aching, unfulfilled connection between us.
But this man was so much more than I’d thought. He had layers I could never have imagined. I couldn’t resist wanting to know more. I kept my voice steady as I said, “She left when you were young, right?” He narrowed his eyes at me, and I put up my hands. “No one else in this town likes secrets, either,” I answered, lips twitching. “Or, more accurately, they love secrets, but only when they can tell everyone about them.”