“Name?” Paul asked, pulling out his notebook.
She flicked that baleful gaze over to him and said, “Can’t you just wave this off?” She stood up and wavered on her feet, and I had to stop myself from reaching over to steady her. “You don’t need to write a report.”
“I do, actually,” Paul replied. “But don’t worry; you’re not in trouble. Name?”
Her shoulders slumped. “Caroline Black,” she said, voice thin.
“Middle name?”
It looked like all the happiness got sucked right out of her. “Eleanor,” she whispered.
“Would you say you’re about five foot four?”
“Five-five,” she said. “And a half.”
“Okie dokie,” Paul said, and even I felt a pang of irritation toward him. But I was glad? Caroline deserved to squirm, because she’d tried to slither into this town with her demons and her dark past, and that would only bring trouble. We didn’t need that here.
“Eye color?”
“Hazel,” she whispered.
“Right. I’m not sure the system accepts hazel, so would you say brown or green?”
“Goddamn it, Paul, just look at her eyes and decide for yourself,” I snapped.
“Brown it is,” he said. “I’ll, um, write this up. Don’t you worry, Ms. Black. Like I said, you’re not in trouble.”
She just stared at the gravel between her feet and crumpled in on herself as Paul nodded at me and walked back to his patrol car.
The door to the bakery was open, spilling warm, yellow light and the scent of baking, so I could see the way her throat worked. Her jaw clenched for a long moment, and then she turned to look at me with cold, cold eyes.
My chest went hollow, but I wouldn’t feel bad about this. “You killed a man,” I said.
She didn’t flinch. Didn’t react at all. Just looked at me and said, “Are you going to tell anyone?”
In that question, I learned her deepest fear: that people would find out. That her precious fresh start would be marred by the truth of her past. The bit of sympathy her pathetic show for Paul had elicited vanished. Shallow, vain, lying woman.
I wouldn’t tell anyone. Yet. The secrets I uncovered were mine to keep. But I didn’t have to tell her that. “I haven’t decided yet.”
“Did you tell him?” She nodded down the alley where the deputy’s taillights disappeared around a corner. “Is that why he agreed to come by so early in the morning?”
“No. He agreed because it was his job, and he was on duty.” Paul would be able to find out, of course, if he was ever curious about her. But he’d have to go digging the way I did, through old records and court filings, and I knew my distant cousin cared more about whatever game was on TV than he did about digging up dirt about the people in this town.
She didn’t know that, though.
Caroline faced me fully then, lifting her chin as she speared me with her cold gaze. “If you ever set foot in my bakery again, I will fucking eviscerate you.”
“I’d like to see you try, sunshine.” The nickname was a jab. There wasn’t a single sunny thing about her. I stepped up to her, looking down at her tear-streaked face, lips curling into a snarl. “I don’t appreciate you coming to my town and lying to my face. If you ever—and I mean ever—cause even an ounce of trouble, I will run your ass out of town faster than you can blink. Consider this your only warning.”
Her jaw clenched so hard the corners bulged. Hatred flared in her hazel eyes, and I welcomed it.
And, three weeks later, when I saw a Grand Opening banner on the front of her bakery, I walked right in despite her threats, because she could hate me all she wanted, but she would always know that I knew the truth about her.
Her head snapped up as soon as I crossed the threshold. A snarl curled her lips.
Next thing I knew, a donut was flying at my head.
NINE