He gave me a flat look. I was a terrible liar, apparently.
I changed tack. “Whether or not I leave has nothing to do with the fact that you need urgent medical attention.”
“I’m fine.”
“Oh my God. All men are the same.”
His lips tipped up. I hated how handsome he was when he smiled. Or scowled. Or existed. “Caroline,” he rumbled, grinning, and my name on his tongue had the same effect it had the first time. Like his voice had a direct line to my clit. He was doing it on purpose.
“Why are you looking at me like that?” I demanded.
“Like what?”
“Like you’re…” Enamored. I scowled at the word that popped into my head and stomped away from his stupid, beautiful face and his big, manly body. I shoved the trash in the garbage and tossed the dirty dish towel and the cloth I’d used to clean his skin in the sink. Then I scrubbed my hands with all the fury consuming my five-foot-five body.
“Aren’t you going to ask me why I don’t want you to leave town?” he asked from the couch. His arms were still spread across the back of it, his fingers brushing both edges of it. Even though I’d seen him nearly every day for years, I hadn’t quite realized how enormous he was.
His presence made me feel…safe.
My scowl deepened. I needed to have a talk with my body, and my mind, and hell, how about my heart too for good measure. Everything had gone haywire. Knox was not safe. I’d learned that lesson early, three days after I’d crashed into him. Knox was the least safe person in the world for me, because he was so damn curious and good at his job.
I blamed Enzo. And his brother. And everything that had happened between then and now. My brain was soup, and there was no way for me to think rationally anymore.
And Knox was speaking in riddles.
“No,” I answered, yanking open a drawer to get a fresh dish towel. “I’m not going to ask you anything.” Droplets of water sprinkled over the floor and cabinets from my wet hands. I dried my hands and then scrubbed at the wet spots, angry.
In my peripheral vision, I watched Knox get off the couch and stalk toward me. I kept my eyes on the countertop, using the edge of my dish towel to scour the dampness out of the grout between the tiles, for whatever good that would do. Big palms landed on the counter across from me, on the other side of the peninsula that separated the kitchen and living areas. I stared at the blood staining three of his fingernails.
Blood he’d shed because of me. No one had ever bled for me before. I was always the one who did the bleeding.
I looked up. Met his navy eyes.
“I don’t want you to leave because this town is your home, Caroline,” he said, his voice quiet. “Just like it’s mine. And I’m not going to let some pointy-shoed, slick-haired asshole run you out of it.”
Relief and disappointment crashed into me. Relief that he wasn’t enamored with me. Our relationship was exactly what I had always thought it was: antagonistic and shallow. And disappointment because he wasn’t enamored with me, and our relationship was exactly what I had always thought it was: antagonistic and shallow.
What had I expected? For him to say he didn’t want me to leave because he liked me? Had I learned nothing from the incident all those years ago?
“So this is just about your ego,” I said. “You don’t want anyone messing with your town.”
“Something like that.” He stared at me, gaze intense. “Who was he, Caroline?”
“None of your business.”
“It became my business the minute he came into my town and attacked you.”
“What are you, a sheriff from the Wild West?” I pointed finger guns at him. “This town ain’t big enough for the both of us, bucko.”
Knox was not distracted by my antics. “You’re going to tell me who he was, and I’m going to help you get rid of him.”
Oh, God, I wanted that. I wanted that so bad. I wanted to keep my polka-dot couch and my yellow vase and my mismatched artwork and my bakery and my friends. I wanted to go to Thursday night trivia at the local dive bar. I wanted to throw donuts at Knox’s head.
“Tell me who he is.” Knox’s voice was low. Coaxing.
I couldn’t give in. Couldn’t bring myself to say it.
“Caroline.”