Walking out was unforgivable, but I would do anything to protect my sister. I had already done awful things to save her. I’d discovered I had a monster inside, questioned my every thought and motivation, and realized that deep down, I wasn’t a good person—and it was all worth it because my sister and nephew were alive and safe.
I could leave a twenty-two-year-old woman alone in this bakery to achieve the same goal. It was far from the worst thing I’d ever done. So, as I untied my apron and strode through the back of the bakery, I said a silent goodbye to the business and the town that had been my home for over four and a half years and a silent apology to all the people who would be impacted by my disappearance.
I’d cry about it later. For now, I had to survive.
KNOX
I’d been lied to before, and every time, it felt like an uncomfortable itch under my skin. I couldn’t bear it. I hated when people hid things from me, when they let me be blindsided by life’s punches.
Right now, the itch was as intense as it had ever been.
I knew Caroline was lying to me. I could feel it like a tick crawling up my leg, looking for the perfect place to sink its mandibles into my skin and start sucking. I wanted to find the lie and burn it with a match, exposing every molecule of it to light and heat. Let the fire of truth consume it until nothing was left but ash.
I thought I’d discovered all of Caroline’s secrets four and a half years ago. I thought I had her figured out. As I walked out of Knead More Bread, I began to wonder if I was wrong.
And I decided it was time for me to find out.
FOUR
CAROLINE
FOUR YEARS AND EIGHT MONTHS AGO
Two days before The Incident With Knox Mars
Splotches of spackle dotted the bakery walls, most of them at hip height where the backs of chairs had knocked gouges into the drywall. I made my way around the room, sanding the spots smooth as my shoulders and arms ached from the effort. I’d been spackling and sanding for six hours already, and it wasn’t even noon.
Silver lining: spending three years being so anxious you couldn’t sleep was great for getting things done before lunchtime.
After this, I’d take a small break to eat, then start priming the walls for paint.
When I reached the last spot of spackle, there was movement outside the windows. Knox Mars paused on the other side of the big pane to my right and lifted a bag. “Lunch,” he said through the window.
My chest warmed, and I bit my bottom lip to stop the smile from spreading over my lips. He grinned at me anyway, like he could tell I was pleased.
This was bad. I’d gone to bed last night thinking of him, and I’d spent the morning convincing myself yesterday had meant nothing. I’d crashed into him, he’d done a good deed, and that was that. I’d keep my distance from him and keep my secrets safe. The end.
I could not, under any circumstances, become involved with Knox Mars.
But he was here, staring at me through the glass, and I was so starved for human contact that I couldn’t resist crossing to the door to unlock it. He joined me there, casting a glance around the room before letting his gaze settle on me. Suddenly, I felt warmer.
“Is this a kink?” I asked, nodding to the food. I spied two log shapes wrapped in paper, and I guessed he’d brought sub sandwiches. “Are you a feeder?”
“I like how you go on the attack when you feel uncomfortable with me being nice to you,” Knox said, crossing the threshold like he owned the bakery instead of me. “It’s cute.”
“I am not cute,” I said, outraged.
He grinned. “Turkey or ham?”
“I haven’t decided if I want to accept yet.”
“I’ll have ham, then.” He tossed the sandwiches onto a table as he sat down, long legs stretching out before him. His gaze circled the space, inspecting my work. “You should keep the door open, get some airflow in here. Especially when you start painting.”
“Hmm,” I answered noncommittally. He was right, of course, but keeping a door unlocked and open while I worked in here made me twitchy. What if someone walked in and threatened me?
Then again, the door would be opened and unlocked when the bakery was operational, wouldn’t it? I needed to get used to acting like a normal human again.
With that in mind, I slid into a chair across from Knox and took the turkey sandwich from the paper bag. He’d also brought two bottles of water, and I cracked one open to guzzle a few greedy gulps. Knox watched me take a bite, and his shoulders seemed to settle slightly. As if he was glad to see me eating…as if he liked taking care of me.