What the actual fuck is going on?
I swear I’m being punked right now, except they aren’t chuckling or waiting for a reaction. From a hall closet, they pull out a folding table and four chairs, setting them up in the giant empty space.
The guys debate without my input which game would be the best for me to play with them. Amused, I watch them. It definitely sounds like it's not the first time they’ve argued over which one to play with me.
I clear my throat to remind them I’m in the room.
They appear startled by my presence, then Zeke asks, “Do you have a preference?”
I eye their selection of games, taking into account what game they were all arguing for, but I pick something none of them have mentioned. “How about Cards Against Humanity?”
Zeke frowns. “But the strategy is that you have to know what the card czar for that turn will like best as a match.”
“Yeah, exactly.” I shrug. “But it’ll be fun to see if I can pick correctly for each of you. And if you can figure out what I’ll find the most amusing.”
We deal out the cards and begin to play. I find it hilarious that I’m doing quite well even though I know them the least. And somehow they seem to pick up on my sense of humor. It’s strange how a game like this can reveal how even new friends can get each other.
I ask where the bathroom is, and they direct me down the hallway. I quickly do my business, and as I exit, I hear them whispering. Perfect. I tiptoe down the hallway to take a peek into their rooms. Invasive? Yes. Does my nosy self do it anyway? Again, yes.
I peek in the open doors, noting that each bedroom has nothing on the walls and nothing of note displayed on their dressers or around the room. Maybe everything is in their closets or under their bed. If it’s not, then I really need to wonder why they are such minimalists, and if I can fit in with that.
When I return to the living room, they’re all smiles. Hmm, that’s not concerning at all.
Then I realize they’re just excited to continue our game.
What would it be like if I had this cozy family vibe in my future permanently? I don’t think I’d hate it.
When our cookies have cooled, we’re ready to apply the icing.
“Should we do another round of cocktails or would you like ice cream?” Conrad asks.
“Uh, the answer is always sweets!” I joke, but I’m not really joking.
Conrad pulls a carton out of the freezer. The I Scream Shop label is plastered on the side. “I got the vanilla chocolate caramel swirl you liked so much.”
I’m flabbergasted that he remembers my go-to flavor. “Wow. That’s so thoughtful of you.”
“I also got a buttercream and berries flavor, if we gobble this one up.”
“Buttercream and berries?” I ask.
“Yeah, uh, for some reason, it reminded me of you.”
Huh, my shifter schoolmate, Quade said I smelled like that. Could it be they have just picked up on that scent? Maybe my scent projects more than I thought, even to human senses. There’s no way they could have supernatural blood, could they? I don’t even know how to broach that subject. Technically, I can’t. If they’re human, that’s a violation of the Supernatural Protections Act.
Conrad dishes a small bowl of ice cream for each of us. I brush off my worries and get to icing the cookies.
“How do you paint the designs?” Silas asks.
I pull out my detail brushes and food dyes so we can paint the white icing, and he smiles. Wow. His handsome face lights up my heart when he smiles and makes my downstairs pulse with my heartbeat. I squeeze my thighs together and try to focus on cookies.
I can’t get over what they do to me. I wonder what it would be like to kiss Silas. I sure hope my next conversation with them means I get to.
The guys opt to watch me decorate the cookies for a bit before diving in themselves. They have a lot of suggestions about what sort of monsters we paint. Krakens, basilisks, and sphinxes seem to be at the top of their list. Not the most common, but they’re a bit odd, and I like the challenge.
Zeke leans over me as I finish painting my second cookie—a blue kraken. “Your cookies are so good, you could make these for a living.”
“Really?” I sit with that thought for a moment as I admire my work. These ‘monster’ cookies are pretty fun. And it isn’t like cookies and treats don’t sell. I could give the brand a gourmet, but fun aesthetic vibe.