“You should loosen up.”
I pretend to be scandalized, and she laughs. The sound sends goosebumps up and down my arms. Fuck, I’m obsessed with everything about her.
“I’ll think about it,” I concede.
“I’m going to hold you to that, De’Andomer.”
The rest of the evening passes too quickly. Elliott sings again, this time on her own, and I can’t take my eyes off her. With her short stature, dark hair, and bright eyes, she looks like everything I’ve ever wanted and every bad decision I’ve ever made.
Bridget notices me staring. “Got it bad, huh?”
I don’t even try to deny it this time. “Unfortunately.”
“Excuse me? It’s an honor to be obsessed with Elliott Elstern. If you don’t change that attitude, I’ll stop feeding you secret intel about where she’s staying on all her road trips.”
“You wouldn’t!”
“I absolutely would if I thought you were taking her for granted for even one second.”
“I’m not.” She raises an eyebrow. “I promise. I just hate that I can’t do anything about it. That we have to be friends.”
She doesn’t say anything. Elliott and I are in an impossible situation. The longer we let things go on, the harder the fall will be when it inevitably comes, but I can’t bring myself to care. When Elliott finishes her song, Raskolnikov and Kat say their goodbyes, prompting our small group to call it a night. Bridget lets slip that the two of them walked here, and both Logan and I protest them walking back alone. Neither woman puts up too much fuss when we insist they let us walk them back to Bridget’s condo.
“How did karaoke night start?” Elliott asks as we make our way down the sidewalk side by side, Logan and Bridget ahead of us.
“It was three years ago, when the team originated,” I explain. “I’d just been named captain, and the team was struggling with our chemistry. Even more than last year. The coaching staff tried everything. Every corporate team building company, every youth hockey drill. Nothing worked.” As I speak, she stares at me with rapt attention, like I’m the most interesting person in the world. “So I had Ops send out a cryptic message, telling everyone there was a mandatory team meeting. All they gave them was the address. Then I had the social team pretend to ask everyone what their walk-up song would be if they were baseball players, and made everyone sing their walk-up song.” Elliott laughs, and I think I might die in order to hear it forever.
That might be the only way I can.
“Did it work?” she asks.
“Despite all the grumbling initially from the older guys, it did. We played a little better, so next time we were at home, I required that everyone come to karaoke again. And thus the tradition was born.”
“So you come every Wednesday you’re in town during the season?”
“Not the whole team, obviously. Players cycle in and out, but there’s always someone from the Storm here when we’re home. Rascal and Kat are big regulars. A few years ago, the owners let me know they were struggling to stay afloat, and it seemed so important to our team’s history that a few of us went in together to bail the owner out. I technically own the place, along with Rascal and two others.” She stares at me intently, like she’s trying to figure something out. “What?”
She shakes her head. “Nothing. Just thinking.”
“Uh oh, that sounds dangerous.”
“It might just be,” she says cryptically as we reach our destination, a small smile playing on her lips. “Good night, Aidan.”
“Good night, Elliott.”
As Logan and I silently make our way back to our cars, both of our thoughts consumed by the women we just left, my smile never leaves my face. I can’t help but wonder once again what would have happened tonight if Elliott hadn’t been too inebriated to make a consensual decision about how the night would go. If she’d been sober when she kissed me, when she’d crawled on my lap. Despite my fears and confusion, I know the answer.
If Elliott had been sober tonight, she’d be mine.
Chapter 11
December
Elliott
“Okay, so you know how I always say that I’m your friend and not your therapist?” Bridget says to me over the phone a week after Thanksgiving. A week and one day since I kissed Aidan.
“Uh, sure?” I stuff my toiletries into my bag, off to the next city, phone tucked between my shoulder and my ear so I can talk hands free. My hotel delivery from Aidan today was a sweatshirt with a cartoon potato on it, a callback to my mortifying comment at karaoke. Under the potato is the comment itself, I shrivel up like a weird little potato, eliminating any doubt I might have had that it wasn’t custom ordered. Now I’m trying to fit it into the delicate balance that is my suitcase, and it’s not going well. When Bridget called, I couldn’t help but tell her about the ridiculous sweatshirt, our conversation shifting to the more scandalous thing that happened on karaoke night.