As always, I take the longer way to the main house. I’m a few minutes early anyway, and I love walking along the edge of the island, listening to the waves smash up against the rocks and the sound of sea spray. It really doesn’t matter I’ve been around it my entire life. I could never get enough.
It snows just enough to make the wooded parts of the island look mystical and to send a chill down my body, but not enough to accumulate a whole lot on the ground. Tonight, though, I think will be a different story. Sometime after midnight, we’re supposed to get three to five inches. Which, in Maine, could mean we get none, or it could mean we get seven. The weatherman likes to keep us all guessing, and sometimes, I’m not entirely sure where he gets his data.
I walk along the edge of the water for as long as I can before it’s time to cut toward the center, and when I do, it’s just dim enough out to see all the lights on in the huge cabin where my parents and Katherine and Mathew plan to stay. It’s a sight I wondered if I’d ever get the chance to witness again, and I stop to take it in for a moment, letting the warm rush flood through my chest.
As I finally walk closer, almost to the front door, I can see my dad and Mathew, each in their respective recliner, watching something on TV. They look like no time has passed—and that the past year and a half was nothing but a bad dream.
I wish.
In the end, this was my father’s fault, and I should have done a lot of things differently. But I can’t turn back the clock, can’t change anything I did or the decisions I made. So all I can do now is try to make it right. I don’t know where this leaves Easton and me. I know what I want, but I’m too scared to ask for it. Right now anyway. It seems so soon.
Too soon. I’d scare him away.
Easton struts into the kitchen, taking a seat on the couch by himself while I see the rest of his siblings and Stella at the kitchen counter behind them. He says something to my dad before grinning—that shit-eating grin that’s always been his signature thing, but for a while, I hadn’t seen it.
I’m glad to see it’s back along with the sparkle in his eyes.
I wrap my fingers around the doorknob and push it open. Even in the entryway, the laughter and chatter is intoxicating, and within seconds, not only Crabcake, but also Ridge’s dog, Marlin, are welcoming me, wiggling around. Once I step inside the house, they take off, Crabcake first and Marlin barreling behind him.
Katherine and my mom work in the kitchen, side by side, but within seconds, I feel a set of eyes on me, and I know just who they belong to.
I lift my gaze to the couch, my entire face flooding with heat when Easton is looking directly at me, a knowing look in his eye. We didn’t talk about what we’d say to our family or how we’d play things off, but I’m guessing we just try to act like everything is normal. Like I didn’t just give him a blowjob before shoving my own finger in his mouth—cringe—and we also don’t hate each other. Somewhere in between, I suppose?
It’s hard to do, but eventually, I tear my eyes from him and head toward our moms.
“Hey, Blairy!” Riley says, propped up at the bar in the kitchen, and I’m not surprised that suddenly, it’s like everything in his world is fine between us. He’s kind of like a goldfish that way, but it’s what makes him so easygoing. Riley doesn’t get shaken up about anything. Well, other than maybe figuring out what girl he’s taking home each night because he’s a playboy, for sure.
“Hey, Ry,” I say, patting his shoulder, and when Tucker looks over at me, smiling, I do the same.
Stella’s disappeared somewhere, and Ridge may be sitting on the other side of Tucker, but he doesn’t look my way, so I pass by him.
“Need help with anything?” I ask Katherine and my mom, and they look at each other and giggle.
“I mean, I can set the table or something,” I add, knowing damn well they are both aware I can’t cook anything. Maybe I could, but I don’t really want to.
“That would be great, sweetie.” My mom smiles, patting my arm, and I head toward the cabinet where all the plates are kept.
Standing on my tiptoes, I reach for the dishes I need on the top shelf, but before I have to climb up on the side of the counter, a warm body crowds against me and arms reach over my head, grabbing them with ease.
“Here, I’ll get it.”
I don’t even have to turn around to know it’s Easton. I’d know his delicious scent anywhere, and I can’t stop myself from inhaling sharply, breathing him in.
“Thanks,” I whisper, wondering if anyone saw that interaction and thinks it’s weird we’re so close to each other. Gosh, I hope not. Not because I want to take back what happened—I don’t—but because I’m not ready to answer those questions right now.
Those many, many questions. I know our families; they’d have a lot.
Once he gets them down, he steps back, and I take it upon myself to get the ones closest to me before I finally turn around. Like little kids, we smile nervously at each other, almost like we have a secret no one else knows. Funny … we do.
That’s sort of how it’s always felt though—until the falling out. It was like we always knew what the other was thinking, and even in a room filled with other people, it was just the two of us.
I follow Easton to the table, and we start setting up. Stealing glances. Heated moments. Ones where I think about what we did an hour ago, and the look in his eye tells me he’s thinking about it too.
I don’t know that girl today who was so fearless and assertive, but I guess after years of wanting my best friend that way, I finally reached my breaking point. I had to have him. I was desperate to be close—closer than we’d ever been. And I guess that desperation … well, it made me brave.
“Hey, I grabbed some glasses,” Stella says, setting them down. “I’ll grab more and then put them at each setting.” She smiles at me when I turn her way, holding her hand out. “By the way, I’m Stella. I know we’ve seen each other around a bit, but we haven’t officially met in person yet.”
Stella’s beautiful. With her auburn hair and big green eyes and porcelain skin, she’s stunning. I shake her hand before gently releasing it, smiling back at her.