His smile fades. Just slightly. His hand flexes at his side, and when he speaks again, his voice is quieter, almost like he’s asked himself the same question a hundred times. “I’d slit my own throat before I’d ever hurt you.”
Do I believe him?
I think I do. Though why I believe him is a mystery only my psychologist can answer. A year ago, I watched Jack kill a man in cold blood. So, out of all the people on this planet, he’s the last person I should trust. But tell that to my stupid fluttering heart.
He steps into my space, close enough that I have to tip my head back to meet his gaze. “There’s one question I’ve been asking myself for a year—why did you run from me in Blackwood Bay? Why?”
“You know why,” I say, echoing his earlier words.
“All I’ve ever wanted to do is protect you,” he says, like that justifies everything.
“Protect me?” A broken laugh claws its way out of my throat. “Jack, you killed a living, breathing person.”
“Actually, I’ve killed three.”
Silence settles between us.
Three.
One is hard enough for me to believe, and I saw it happen with my own eyes. I stare at him, looking for any sign he’s messing with me, but his face is totally blank.
“You’re lying,” I manage to squeak out.
“I’ve never lied to you.” He says, dragging his thumb from the corner of my mouth to the center of my bottom lip. “I don’t need to. You already know what I am.”
“Then who—” I stop myself. Do I actually want to know? Some sick, curious part of me does. The part that’s been starving for a year, filling in the blanks with explanations that never quite fit.
“Ask me.” His pale eyes hold mine like he wants to tell me. “Go on, baby—ask me the next question. The one you’ve been too terrified to ask…”
There is something I’ve always wondered, but been too afraid to ask, scared of what the answer might do to me.
But tonight, I need to know.
EMILIA
“Just say it,” I whisper, still too afraid to ask him outright.
Jack stands over me, his eyes darker somehow. “You already know about Derek,” he says easily, like that was no big deal. “The first guy I killed was the asshole who exposed himself to you outside the coffee shop in San Francisco.”
Wait, what? That throws me. The thing in San Francisco happened years ago, during a class trip to visit Alcatraz our sophomore year. Jack wasn’t in the class, so he wasn’t allowed on the trip. And I didn’t tell him about the creepy guy until I got home three days later. He couldn’t have even known who the guy was, let alone how to find him. Unless…
I swallow. “Were you watching me in San Francisco?”
He studies my face carefully, but doesn’t say anything.
“Answer me.”
“Yes, I was in San Francisco,” he answers evenly.
I nod slowly, absorbing that. So, he was stalking me even when we were together. I wish I could say I'm surprised, but I'm not.
“How long?” I ask. “How long were you watching me?”
A ghost of a smile touches his lips. “Since freshman year.”
Freshman year? Okay, now that surprises me. That’s one whole year before San Francisco. One whole year before I even knew he existed. Maybe he's remembering the timeline wrong. "We didn’t meet until sophomore year,” I point out.
“We didn’t talk until sophomore year.” He says, like the distinction should’ve been obvious. “I saw you on the first day of freshman orientation, when we were picking up our schedules. You were wearing a jean skirt, your hair was pulled back into a ponytail, and you had a black backpack. You tripped on the steps in the quad, and instead of being embarrassed, you laughed at yourself.” His steady gaze makes me feel like an insect pinned to a board. “And when that was no longer enough, the next year, I arranged to have a class with you…”