Page 94 of The Realest Witch

Page List

Font Size:

I turn away from the window, remembering the conversations I’d had with my mother about the prowl’s decision to relocate. We needed more land, more room for our families to grow, and Onyx Hollow offered us a chance to build something without constantly worrying about how much space we had left. There were already established Jaguar communities throughout the South, and moving closer to them had made sense for a lot of reasons. Nobody had expected our departure to affect the covenant the way it had.

“Mom, we didn’t leave Ruby Springs because we wanted to break our connection to the Wyatts. We left because we needed room to grow, and everybody understood that. Samuel had no reason to believe Celeste and Nathaniel were coming to demand we move back.”

“You’re right, Kareem, but he wasn’t thinking reasonably. He believed the covenant had become a burden, and when the cubs began experiencing problems, he refused to accept that our departure might be responsible. Hearing that the Wyatts had found something only made him more afraid that the elders would insist on returning to Ruby Springs, and he decided to prevent that conversation from happening.”

I close my eyes, struggling to contain the anger rising through me. “He could’ve listened to them. He could’ve waited until they arrived and heard what they had to say, but instead he decided two people needed to die because he was afraid of something that hadn’t even happened.”

“I know, sweetheart. He admitted that himself. He said he acted out of fear, and that he never imagined the consequences would be so devastating.”

“Consequences?” I repeat, the word leaving a bitter taste in my mouth. “Those consequences are two dead parents and their children who’ve spent the last two years trying to survive without them. Bea has been raising her little sister, running that diner, and doing everything she can to keep their lives together, while Zane’s magic has been getting more dangerous by the day. All this time, the man responsible has been sitting on your council, watching everybody struggle to find answers.”

My mother doesn’t try to defend him, and I’m grateful for that because I don’t think I could bear to hear anybody offer an excuse for what he’s done.

“He acted alone, Kareem. None of the other elders knew what he was planning, and he used his authority to make sure nobody questioned the findings submitted through our office. When I began asking about the discrepancies you’d uncovered, he knew we were getting closer to the truth. Then that little boy was brought in last night, and seeing another child suffering finally pushed him to confess.”

I press my fingers against my forehead, thinking about the two reports sitting on my desk and all the unanswered requests Sue has sent to Onyx Hollow. I’d known there was something wrong with the investigation, and hearing my mother confirm it should bring some sense of relief that I wasn’t chasing something that didn’t exist. Instead, I feel sick.

“What’s happening to him now?” I ask, forcing myself to focus on the part of this situation I might actually be able to do something about. “Please tell me he’s not still sitting in a council chamber somewhere, asking everybody to forgive him.”

“Absolutely not. He’s been taken into custody, suspended from his position, and the council is cooperating fully with the authorities here in Onyx Hollow. His confession will be formally recorded, and the original investigation is being reopened. Samuel will answer for what he’s done, Kareem, I intend to make sure of it.”

I want to tell her that isn’t enough, that I’d like nothing more than to travel to Onyx Hollow and look Caldwell in the face while he explains how he justified murdering the parents of the woman I love. Part of me wants to be the one who puts the cuffs on him, who makes him understand exactly what his actions have cost the people he claimed to be protecting.

But I can’t leave Ruby Springs, and even if I could, there’s nothing I’d accomplish by going there that would bring Celeste and Nathaniel back.

“Mom, I don’t even know what I’m supposed to do with this information.” I pull out one of the chairs near the table and sit down heavily, leaning forward with my elbows resting on my knees. “Bea watched her family home burn to the ground last night. Zane already blames herself for what happened, and neither one of them has had a chance to recover from losing everything they grew up with. Now I’ve got to walk into that house and tell them their parents didn’t die in an accident after all, that somebody from my own prowl deliberately took them away.”

My mother’s breath catches, and for a moment, neither of us says anything. I can hear the faint sounds of people talking somewhere on her end, and I wonder how many members of the council are sitting there trying to make sense of the same confession that’s turned my morning upside down.

“I wish I could tell you there was an easy way to do this, baby,” she finally says, her voice thick with emotion. “But those girls deserve to know what happened to their parents, and they deserve to hear it from somebody who loves them. You can’t protect them from the truth by keeping it to yourself, no matter how badly you want to spare them the pain.”

I know she’s right, which only makes the situation harder to accept. I’ve spent most of my life believing that if I worked hard enough, paid attention, and did what needed to be done, I could protect the people depending on me. It’s one of the reasons I became a sheriff, and it’s something my Jaguar understands as deeply as I do.

Yet here I am, knowing that the next thing I have to do is hurt two people I’d give my life to protect.

“As tragic as all of this is, Samuel’s confession doesn’t change what’s happening to our cubs,” my mother continues, the frustration in her voice unmistakable. “Those poor children are still suffering, and we’re no closer to finding a way to repair the covenant. Celeste and Nathaniel might’ve had the answers we needed, but because of one man’s selfishness and fear, we’ll never know what they discovered unless somebody can find their research or piece together what they were trying to tell us.”

I sit back, staring at the floor as I think things through. For weeks, I’d believed the accident investigation might lead us to the missing piece of the puzzle. If somebody had interfered with the Wyatts’ journey, there had to be a reason, and I’d hoped understanding that reason might tell us what they’d discovered. Now I know why they were stopped, but the answer doesn’t bring us any closer to helping Zane or the cubs.

“We’re still searching,” I tell her, rubbing my hands over my face. “Ezra and Idris have found evidence that the markings we carry are connected to the Wyatt family, and Bea’s been trying to understand what her parents knew about the original covenant. We’ve made progress, but we still don’t know what we’re supposed to do with any of it.”

“Then you keep looking, Kareem. Samuel’s actions were his own, and he’ll face the consequences here. Right now, your place is in Ruby Springs with Bea and Zane, and the rest of us will continue doing everything we can for the children until you find an answer.”

I let out a long breath, wishing I could offer her something more reassuring than another promise that we’re trying. The cubs have suffered for far too long, and the situation is getting worse while we search through old records and try to piece together a covenant nobody fully understands anymore.

“Call me as soon as you hear anything more about Caldwell,” I tell her, rising from the chair and making my way toward the door. “I want copies of his confession and whatever the investigators uncover. Sue and I have spent too much time on this case to leave the rest of it unanswered.”

“You’ll have everything you’re entitled to, sweetheart. I’ll make sure of it.”

I pause with my hand resting on the doorknob, trying to find something else to say, but there isn’t much left that wouldn’t sound like another expression of anger or frustration.

“Mom, don’t let him walk away from this.”

Her response comes without hesitation. “He won’t, Kareem. I promise you that.”

I end the call and remain standing in the empty room, looking down at the phone in my hand while I try to gather myself. My Jaguar has been restless since the moment Caldwell’s name entered the conversation, and I can feel his anger pressing against mine, demanding an outlet I can’t give him.

The man responsible for Celeste and Nathaniel Wyatt’s deaths will finally answer for what he did, and under any other circumstances, that would be the kind of breakthrough I’d spent my career hoping to achieve. I’ve followed the evidence, questioned the reports, and refused to accept an explanation that didn’t fit the facts. I was right. The accident wasn’t an accident, and somebody deliberately concealed the truth.


Novels you may like ...