Cassius laughs beneath his breath, but when I look at him, his smile fades. He’s all business.
“I want you too,” he says, throwing the gauntlet down at my feet. His expression is playful, but his eyes aren’t.
I look away from him and find Kareem watching me.
Of course, four against one. Except it isn’t, and that’s the part that bothers me most.
They aren’t ganging up on me. Nobody has demanded anything. Nobody has told me what I’m supposed to do. They are simply sitting there, taking away every argument I’ve spent years preparing to use against them.
Fine. I have another one.
“You don’t know me.” I whisper, giving them more truth than I truly want to.
They all stay silent, waiting for me to continue.
I tighten my grip on the order pad. “You remember a girl who lived here twenty years ago. Kareem has been back long enough to annoy the hell out of me, but the rest of you haven’t even spoken to me until tonight. You don’t know who I am now.”
“No,” Idris says. He holds my gaze. “We don’t.”
His answer catches me completely off guard.
Roman’s fingers move once against the tabletop. “That’s why we’re here, Cookie.”
“To do what?” I ask incredulously.
“Get to know you,” he says sincerely.
The simplicity of it leaves me with absolutely nowhere comfortable to put my irritation.
Cassius smiles. “Preferably without you running every time you see us coming.”
“I. Do. Not. Run.” I reply, stressing every word.
“Bumblebee.” Cassius lifts his brow.
“I don’t.” I lift one shoulder in a shrug.
Kareem’s shoulders shake with silent laughter.
I point at him. “Keep laughing, Kitty Cat. I haven’t forgotten about you.”
The table erupts into laughter at my choice of nickname. Even Idris drops his head and huffs out a laugh. Seeing his joy makes me laugh right along with them.
The plastic knife sticking out of my head chooses that exact moment to wobble forward.
Roman reaches out before I can react and catches the plastic handle between two tattooed fingers.
I freeze. His hand is close enough to my face that I can see the intricate lines of ink disappearing across his knuckles.
He gently straightens the knife, letting his finger linger.
“There you go, Cookie.” He smiles softly at me.
My traitorous stomach flips.
I step back. “Okay. That’s enough.” The laughter fades as I look around the table and make sure every last one of them is paying attention. “I don’t know what brought all of you back here, and maybe there is more going on than I know. Fine. When you’re ready to explain it, I’ll listen.” Idris gives me a small nod. “But whatever is happening with the covenant and whatever you think is happening between the five of us are two different things.”
“They are,” Kareem says.