Maybe it was seeing Fletcher give comfort to my son in a way I couldn’t, or maybe it was the comfort he brought to me, the kind I haven’t known in a long time—if I’ve ever felt it at all, really.
And letting this town take that away from me to save face, well, that feels more like letting them win than anything else.
“I’m tired of the secrets,” I whisper. “I’m tired of the hiding and pretending and feeling like I’m the one doing something wrong.”
Slowly, he lifts his hand and lightly traces his fingertips over my cheek. My eyes flutter shut as a million thoughts war in my mind. Because as much as I want to let it all go, the one thought that trips me up time and time again is…Casey. Tonight—the three of us spending time together—may have been a very, very bad idea.
“I’m just worried if Casey gets attached, that when you leave, it’ll just hurt him more,” I whisper.
He stares at me, the look on his face almost offended. “When? Why are you assuming I will?”
Did I say when? I hadn’t meant to…but I guess that is what I meant. I shrug helplessly. “Because everyone always does.”
His face falls. After a deep breath, he takes one of my hands in his and props the other beneath my chin. The intensity in his eyes pins me to the spot. “Not this time, Chris.”
I lay a hand over his and bring it down from my face. “Look, Fletcher, I’m complicated. I have enough baggage for a lifetime. And you’re young—”
He tightens his fingers around mine before I can let go of his hand. “Don’t do that.”
“Just let me say this. You’re young, Fletcher. I don’t mean that in any bad way, and it’s never something I think about when we’re together, but it’s still true. And I wouldn’t hold it against you if you weren’t ready for everything that being with me—really being with me—entails.”
He’s quiet, and I search his eyes, pleading with him to understand.
But then he murmurs, “Don’t push me away because you think I’m going to leave. Because I’m right here. And I’m not leaving. There is nothing about you or your past that scares me. I have known what I was getting into from the start, and I never would’ve wasted your time if I didn’t think I could handle it.” My eyes burn, and I scrunch my nose as I fight back tears. He frames my face with his hands and angles it up, forcing me to meet his eyes. “I am all in, Chris. But I need to know if you’re all in with me too.”
I don’t know if I’ve ever been all in on something in my life. Keeping one foot out the door is what keeps you safe. Keeps you ready for when disaster inevitably strikes. It doesn’t protect you from the pain altogether, but I imagine it would be ten times worse without it.
“I don’t know if I know how to be,” I admit.
He gives me a soft, sad smile. “I know that feeling. I had it when my parents first took me in. But they helped me through it. Now all I’m asking is for you to let me help you.”
What he’s saying—it sets off every fight or flight alarm bell in my head. My mother’s voice is blended in there somewhere. You can’t trust him. He says that now, but what about in ten years when it’s time to trade you in for a newer model? You’re too broken by now. There’s no fixing you anymore.
“I feel like this is worth taking a leap of faith for,” he adds. “Do you?”
It doesn’t just feel like a leap. It feels like a drop. Out of an airplane. Flying over a deep and endless ocean when I don’t know how to swim.
But that fear tightening my chest, that instinctual urge to run, when I look into Fletcher’s eyes, it quiets in a way I don’t know it ever has before.
“I do too,” I whisper.
Chapter Twenty-Six
FLETCHER
It’s dark by the time Liam drops me off at the skate park. Unsurprisingly, my car is the last one in the lot. As I start the engine and my eyes flick to the rearview mirror, a flash from earlier in the day makes my stomach clench. Casey cowering in the corner, covering his head like he was bracing for impact. I let out a slow breath through my nose and force my jaw to unclench.
It doesn’t hit how tired I am until I pull into my garage. I climb out of the car, eyes barely open, and shuffle toward the door—
—the door that’s already sitting open.
I freeze. There’s no way I left it like that. And if I had, it’s directly in front of my windshield, so I would’ve noticed it once I got in the car.
I grab the baseball bat sitting beside the door, then ease it open.
The house is quiet, dark.
Maybe I’m overreacting. Maybe I did leave the door—