“Lucy,” I say through my teeth.
“I know,” she croaks.
“She was five—”
“I know!” Jacks shouts, tears running down her face now, and she breathes heavily through gritted teeth. “And I’ve carried that with me my entire life—”
“But you still did it again!” I’m shaking. Head to toe I am vibrating with rage. The piece of that night that I never dare to think about, that every cell in my body has been fighting to keep out of my memory floods back.
We made it out the window. I got her out. I got her out. But by the time we were on the ground, she wasn’t breathing.
I remember an ambulance in the street by then. I’d sprinted for it with her in my arms.
They tried everything. CPR. Oxygen. Her throat was so swollen they couldn’t get a tube down it.
I couldn’t hear anything. My ears were ringing. But I was on my knees at her side begging them, begging them, to keep trying.
All these years I’ve blamed myself. I let her go. I didn’t get her out fast enough. I didn’t wake up soon enough. So many little things I could’ve done differently and maybe today she’d still be alive.
I blink back to the room. To the face of the person who started the fire.
Because that noise, that itching that’s been in the back of my mind for months, I remember it now.
It wasn’t Jacks shaking me that woke me up. It was footsteps on the squeaky stairs.
Coming up from the kitchen, down the hall, and then into my room.
Because the cigarettes didn’t start the fire. And I didn’t leave the stove on.
She went down there and set it herself.
“You know what? I might have been able to forgive you for that. We were kids, and you were going after Joan and Bob. I know you didn’t mean for that to happen. But Christine and Casey?” My voice breaks around their names.
For a moment, when I saw Chris buried under the ceiling, I’d thought she was dead. That I was too late.
“Please, Fletcher, you have to forgive me.”
“You tried to kill them.” The heat rises in my chest like my voice is aching to scream, to yell, but the words come out low and quiet and shaking. “Even if we set aside for a second”—I can’t help but laugh because I can’t fucking believe these words are coming out of my mouth—“that killing people, inherently, is wrong. What about me, Jacks? Someone you supposedly care about—”
“I do care about you—”
“Do you have any idea what losing them would’ve done to me?”
I can’t even fathom it. The moment my brain tries, everything inside of me repels it with a vicious desperation.
My life wasn’t bad before Christine. And maybe I could’ve gone on that way forever. But once she stepped into my life, there was no going back. Because knowing what life looked like with her in it—everything was different. The way I breathed, the way I walked, the way my heart beat. She was a vital organ I didn’t know I had, one that had been living outside of my body for the first twenty-three years of my life.
Losing her wouldn’t just devastate me. It would destroy me.
“I know it was wrong. Fletcher, I tried to stop it—”
I bark out a laugh again and pace the length of the room. My entire body is vibrating with restless, uncontrollable energy. My nostrils flare as I meet Jacks’s eyes, and a violence I have never felt floods my veins. I have never thought I’d be capable of hurting someone until now.
Lowly, I force out, “I will never forgive you for this. And if you have even a shred of a soul left you will tell the police exactly what you did when they come in here.”
Her chin wobbles. “Fletcher—”
“Don’t ever speak to me again. Don’t ever come near me or the people I love again. You and me, we are done, Jacks.”