“Nice hat,” she says as she reaches him.
“Nice corset.” He offers his arm. “If you need help getting that off later, just let me know.” He lowers his voice as he says it, but not enough.
Leo chokes next to me, his complexion going red as he looks from his sister to Liam. Before Leo can get any words out, Liam grimaces and whisks Gracie toward the kitchen.
But my attention is locked on the stairs. Time slows as Christine rounds the corner. She bunches the layers of her skirt in her hand as she heads down, and her soft blond curls bounce around her shoulders with each step. She catches my eye and gives me one of those coy little smirks of hers.
“Do you like it?”
She has a corset like Gracie, though hers is covered in thick leather buckles that match the tool belt hung low on her hips. It’s layered over an off-white blouse with puffy sleeves and strings cinching it together at the neckline. Despite my best efforts, I can’t help but stare.
Role-play has never been my thing in the past, but this…this is making me question things about myself.
“You have to stop looking at me like that,” she says lowly.
“Believe me, I’m trying.”
“Help! Help!”
A chorus of screams breaks out in the living room. Christine hooks her arm through mine as we hurry to join them.
In the center of the room lies Jacks, a mess of fake blood covering her throat.
“Arrrg!” cries Casey. “There’s been a murder on the ship!”
Chapter Thirty-Seven
CHRISTINE
Watching Fletcher explain the rules to the room in pirate garb should absolutely not be a turn-on, and yet… I think he needs to start wearing more leather. Like, all the time. The neckline of his shirt is lower than mine, and I am absolutely not staring at the planes of his chest every time he moves.
Once the first round of the game is underway, everyone breaks off to interrogate each other and search for clues. Instead of Casey being glued to my side like he usually is in group settings, it’s like he can’t get away from me fast enough as he and Erin take off, more interested in their sword fight than the details of the game.
The party itself is…impressive, to say the least. Every detail was clearly carefully thought out—the food, the decorations, the costumes, the game—and it almost brings tears to my eyes.
The birthdays I spent with Julian were…cold. Fancy, but hollow. Expensive restaurants, expensive gifts. But they were the kinds of places he could’ve taken anyone, the types of jewelry that held no personal touches. Nothing that ever suggested he knew a damn thing about me.
“Please save me from myself. I can’t stop.”
I blink back to Gloria as she stuffs another handful of the Pirate Booty popcorn in her mouth. I narrow in on the M&Ms mixed in, and I quickly scoop up a handful for myself.
“I should warn you, there is a cake coming up you’ll want to save room for.” Fletcher slides in on my right.
My eyes dart around the rest of the kitchen—the table, the counters. No sign of a cake.
He chuckles and rests his hand against the small of my back. “Tucked away for safe keeping.”
Gloria nods knowingly. “Erin and Casey.”
Fletcher chuckles again, his eyes flicking to me. “Not who I was thinking of, actually.”
I swat him on the chest.
He clears his throat, his expression suddenly serious. “Now, if you’ll excuse us, ma’am, I have some questions for the innkeeper.”
I have to press my lips together to keep from laughing at the way he’s talking out of one corner of his mouth. And what even is that accent?
“Is your pirate from the South?” I whisper.