After pulling myself together in the bathroom and throwing on a pair of Fletcher’s sweats, I make my way to the kitchen. The stairs creak as he follows me down, and I glance over my shoulder as he rounds the corner.
“You. Sit.”
He raises his eyebrows at me in disbelief. “Excuse me?”
“You heard me.” I jut my chin at the barstool and reach for the fridge.
“What do you think you’re doing?”
“Wooing you with my cooking skills, obviously.”
He watches in amusement as I hunt through his cabinets for a pan. “Do you want some help?”
Finally, I find the right one and straighten a little too quickly in my excitement. My head hits the inside of the cabinet with a dull thunk.
“Chris—”
“No. You always do it. So just go sit over there and let me make my boyfriend breakfast for once, okay?”
I compile my finds on the counter—eggs and bread. I can handle eggs and toast—but turn when I realize how uncharacteristically quiet he’s being now.
He’s sitting on a barstool, arms crossed over his chest and watching me with a soft smile.
“What?” I demand.
He shakes his head, and his eyes trace over every detail of my face. Quietly, he murmurs, “I like hearing you call me your boyfriend. And I like having you stay over, that’s all.”
I smirk, my face heating a bit. “That’s just because you haven’t tasted my eggs yet.”
“Please tell me you guys aren’t doing it on the kitchen counter right now!” Jacks calls from the stairs.
“The coast is clear,” Fletcher deadpans.
She appears a moment later with wet hair and slides onto the barstool beside Fletcher. “Why are you up so early?”
I meet his eyes, but that haunted look behind them is gone now, replaced by his usual easy smile. “I don’t know. Keep hearing about this early bird getting a worm or something. Thought I’d give it a shot.”
Chapter Thirty-Six
FLETCHER
I doubt Sweetspire’s tiny costume shop has seen this much business in years. When I tell the little old man behind the counter I need thirteen costumes, his eyes all but fall out of his head. He doesn’t have enough to match the theme, so I take the eight he has and figure we can pick and choose a few pieces for everyone and get creative with the rest.
Casey tears into one of the bags the moment we’re in the truck and slips the eye patch on. He whips toward me with a hooked finger. “Aaarrgggg!”
“Don’t forget the pet monkey.”
He slips that over his shoulder next. “Are you going to be a pirate too?” he asks.
“I don’t know.” I start the car and throw a hand over the back of the passenger seat as I reverse out of the parking lot.
Casey and I got the idea for a costume party while we were browsing for games, but it was Jacks who suggested we make it one of those whodunit murder mystery parties instead.
A few minutes of internet searches later, I found a script to print with a list of characters and instructions on how to host. Murder among the Mateys it’s called, so they’re all pirate themed. Casey’s clearly vying for the pirate captain.
“I figured I’d let everyone else pick their characters and I’d take whatever was left,” I add. “Who do you think we should save for your mom?”
He sifts through the costumes in the seat beside him and I see him pull up the big dress in the rearview mirror.