Everyone is dressed in perfectly coordinated, ultra-expensive loungewear—think matching thousand-dollar Loro Piana cashmere sets or silk pajamas.
She's not in Loro Piana. No, Indigo is in some version of raw silk and linen. It's not pajamas; it's a flowing skirt, blue with flowers on it, and it looks absolutely gorgeous. I mean, she looks absolutely gorgeous in it.
Then there is the forced-intimacy gift exchange.
We sit on priceless Persian rugs and open extremely lavish, hyper-personalized gifts. I kid you not, every gift is passive-aggressive—like Lavinia giving Indigo a stunning Chanel dress that is two sizes too small for her, with a sweet little card: To inspire you in the new year, darling.
And then there is my father, who gives Kayden a luxury watch, reminding him in front of everyone that it cost more than his entire department earned this quarter.
Gia, the only child amongst us, has been put to bed early. Because it's Christmas.
Jesus.
This is Christmas Eve. She should be running around opening gifts. There should be a dog or two. It should be noisy and fun, and instead, it's so choreographed it's offensive.
If I ever have kids, I want them in inappropriate clothing, descending on the wrapping paper like it's war. I want them noisy and loud and happy.
Not this.
There is, obviously, a private chef and a team of white-gloved servants who do all the work, but my mother pretends to have put it all together with Olivia, because—it is so much work, isn't it?
Every flower vase, every table setting, all of it has been manicured by an interior designer.
The conversation is a minefield of polite insults wrapped in compliments. We toast to family unity while actively cutting each other out of trusts and ignoring the obvious affairs, addictions, and bankruptcies brewing at the table.
It is exhausting.
I am exhausted.
Indigo is drinking more than she normally does.
She's exhausted, too.
Grandma isn't having a great day. At eighty-eight, she has good days and bad days, and Paloma is looking a little tired. "I don't think I'm going to make it to Mass at St. Thomas tonight."
"We're not going to St. Thomas, Mother. We're going to St. Bartholomew's in Midtown," Lavinia tells her mother-in-law.
Paloma nods. "Either way, I think I'm going to go to bed."
"Yeah, me too. I'm tired." This comes from Indigo.
"You will not. We always go as a family," Lavinia is quick to say.
Yeah, we do—looking like a picture-perfect, devout dynasty. The truth is, nobody cares about the service. We only attend because we own a prominently placed, endowed family pew. It's entirely about being seen by the other elite families, exchanging air kisses on the church steps, and maintaining our public status before we retreat back to our silent, putrid, freezing limousines.
Speaking of putrid—Indigo called me that. She said I was sick because she thought I was lying about my relationship status with Olivia.
We go to St. Bartholomew's in two limos. Indigo isn't in mine.
The church is doing its job. Candlelight everywhere, the mosaics in the dome catching gold, and the choir warming up something that will make four hundred extremely rich people feel briefly forgiven. Our pew has a small brass plaque on it with the Hale Family name and crest. We came on the Mayflower, hence the crest.
I sit between Olivia and my father, which is its own kind of penance.
Indigo is at the far end, next to the empty space where Paloma should be, in a coat she clearly threw on over the silk and linen, and she's staring up at the dome like she's pricing out the gold leaf.
Twenty minutes in, during a reading, she leans over to her mother, whispers something, and slips out the side of the pew. Lavinia's jaw tightens, but you don't make a scene at St. Barts. That's the entire family religion in one sentence: you don't make a scene.
I give it ninety seconds. Then I tell Olivia I need the restroom, and I don't wait to hear what she says.