“I mostly just sat there trying not to commit crimes.”
His mouth twitches. “A valid strategy, Kentucky.”
I smile faintly, staring out over the dark backyard. For a few quiet seconds, neither of us says anything. And weirdly, it isn’t awkward. It’s comfortable.
“You know,” I say eventually, “I think Blair has convinced my dad that she and I are old friends. Part of me wants to tell him everything.”
“And the other part?”
“The other part sees how happy he is, and I would rather die than ruin it for him.”
Nico studies me for a moment. “You sacrifice a lot for the people you love.”
I shrug awkwardly. “I just don’t want to ruin this for him.”
His gaze lingers on my face. “You’re a good person, Sabrina.”
The compliment embarrasses me. Maybe it’s because it’s Nico saying it. Maybe it’s because he never says anything casually. Before I can respond, the back door suddenly opens behind us. I tense automatically as Blair steps out of the house, but she doesn’t even look toward us. She is holding her cell phone against her ear, already talking as she steps out past the porch. Nico notices immediately. Without a word, he catches my wrist gently and pulls me backwards into the shadows where we are hidden by the side wall of the house. My pulse jumps instantly at the contact.
“Oh my God,” Blair says, laughing softly into her cell phone. “I’m telling you, there’s no way she could ever pull a guy like that.”
I freeze. Beside me, Nico goes completely still.
My stomach twists as Blair laughs again. “No, seriously. It’s Smelly Sabrina, for God’s sake.”
Each word lands like a slap. I stare down at the porch floorboards.
“She’s probably paying him to be her fake boyfriend or some shit like that. It’s exactly the kind of thing she would do.”
Humiliation floods my face. I didn’t fool her for a second.
“She’s always been weird around men,” Blair continues casually. “Like painfully awkward.”
I hear Nico inhale slowly beside me.
“And honestly?” Blair says. “I don’t buy it. It’s all so fake. I mean, you should have heard him, telling all who would hear that she would look beautiful in a trash bag. As if she is some sort of beauty. That little bitch couldn’t look good in a tiara and Gucci. And I’ve never even seen them kiss each other. Not once.”
Something ugly curls in my chest. Of course, she has noticed that we haven’t kissed. She’s been watching for any cracks in my story.
“She acts like she’s won the lottery or something,” Blair says with another mean laugh. “I’m sorry, but she doesn’t fool me. He looks like he belongs on the cover of Forbes. She couldn’t keep a man like that. Never.”
That one hurts. Because a small, horrible part of me still believes that myself. Nico’s hand tightens slightly around my wrist. Not to hurt. Just enough for me to know he’s got me.
Blair sighs dramatically.
“Whatever. It’ll be over after the wedding anyway, and then we’ll know it was all a big fake charade, even if I can’t prove it now.”
My throat feels tight suddenly. And I hate that she still has the ability to do this to me. To reduce me back down to that insecure teenager in seconds. Beside me, Nico shifts. Then, without a single word, he takes my hand fully in his and starts leading me back toward the house. I blink in confusion, trying to keep up quietly as he opens the back door and guides me into the kitchen. My dad must have gone upstairs because the room is empty. Only the soft yellow light above the stove is on.
“Nico …”
“Shh.”
His voice is low and calm. He walks me backwards slowly until my hips hit the kitchen island. Then he positions himself beside me, one hand still wrapped around mine.
“What are you doing?” I whisper.
His eyes flick towards the back door. “Waiting.”