“No, that’s not—” He swallows heavily and lowers his hands. “I don’t want to do this.”
My stomach spasms. He’s changed his mind. That easily?
With shaking hands, I smooth down my skirt.
His eyes widen at whatever he sees in mine. “Not about you,” he amends quickly. “Not about us. Not about… Jenna, I want you so bad—I’ve been wanting you so bad, it has to be seriously unhealthy. At this point you only have to breathe in my direction and I’m losing my mind—”
“Hey.” I grip his face and he fixes me with a frenzied look. “We’re not doing anything you don’t want.”
“I do want it. Here and now, and that’s kind of the point. I’ve done this more times than I’d care to admit. The front door make-out on the first date, stripping down as soon as we get inside… It’s all the same bullshit, over and over again. But I want us to be different. I want us to last and I don’t want to screw this up.”
I smile. “Relationship, remember? It’s already different, Finn.”
But he looks over his shoulder again, at the door of apartment 511, and there’s something else going on here. I want this, so badly, and his logic is shaky at best. But he asked me for slow out in the car, and it’s excruciating but I’m not going to be the one to push him into anything he doesn’t want, especially not when it comes to sex.
I stroke his cheek, drawing back his attention. “Can we still make out a little bit?”
There’s relief over every bit of his face, like he’s silently telling me thank you.
“First, I’m gonna take a cold as hell shower. And then yeah, Jenna Bear. We’ll make out as much as you want.”
Chapter 20
Finn
“Being with Jenna feels a lot like not being with Jenna.”
“Sounds like a fantastic relationship.” Nina smirks, running a cloth around the rim of the plate in front of her before putting it under the heat lamps.
I make a face at her, but the twerp isn’t looking. She calls out a new order to the crew behind us, taking her time adjusting her hair net. I wait her out. Finally, she can’t do a thing but look back and I grimace at her worse this time.
“What I mean you little jerk, is that beyond the added perks of making out and having her in my bed at night—”
“To cuddle?” Nina says, eyeing me carefully. “You’re still just cuddling?”
The woman has no indoor voice. The two line cooks to my right exchange a look. I lean my hip against the counter.
“Yes, we’re still just cuddling,” I confirm, adjusting my glasses. “Why do you keep looking at me like that whenever I tell you this?”
“I’m not looking at you like anything.” She turns to prep the two plates of sea bass in front of her. “It’s just… You know. You’re Finn Palmer. Whenever I thought about you getting your head out of your ass long enough to ask her to be with you—”
“How would you know I was going to do that? I only decided last night.”
She gives me a look that says come on. “Whenever I thought about you getting your head out of your ass long enough to ask her to be with you, I also thought you’d have her bedridden for a week. You’ve been celibate for a year—”
“Woah.” One of the line cooks looks at me with his jaw dropped.
“Quiet, you,” I tell him. Turning back to Nina, I say: “It’s not like I don’t want to. Honestly, our water bill has gotten a little out of control with all the time I spend in the shower—”
“Why do I need to hear about that—”
“And the conclusion I’ve drawn is that I’m a victim of my reputation. It’s a lot of pressure to deliver on, you know? She knows about… Well, she knows about everything. And I don’t know how to live up to it.”
“And what’s her excuse? Why isn’t she jumping your bones yet? Don’t tell me you fell for a sweet, chaste virgin—”
“Don’t,” I cut in, jabbing a finger at her. “I don’t see how that’s any of your business.”
She gives an acquiescing nod, taking the reproach on the chin. “You know, I’m proud of you, big guy. Finn Palmer, all grown up. I never thought I’d see the day.”