He was right, the other night.
We fit together perfectly. His chin barely dips and his lips find mine. For a moment, Finn kisses me sweet. It’s soft, the way he takes my lower lip, my top lip, gently sucking, grazing my tongue with his. The way his hand gently holds my face, fingers brush my cheek.
It feels like meeting for the first time. Like catching his eye across a crowded bar, and not being able to look away. Those butterflies, that flutter of anticipation as he approaches, that first smile. The first touch as he takes your hand. Not knowing how far this thing will go, or what you’re meant to be to each other.
It’s the kind of kiss you’ve been waiting to give someone, after months of wanting.
With a swipe of my cheek with his thumb, a last gentle kiss, Finn draws back. Presses his forehead to mine and he’s smiling, so big and crooked I can’t help but give it right back to him. I feel so lightheaded I let out a giddy giggle, and Finn swipes my mouth with his fingers.
“I’ve been dying to do that. Dying for it, Jenna.”
He doesn’t let me catch my breath. Finn crashes his mouth on mine again. Tilts his head, drops both hands to my hips, tightens his grip. And the kiss becomes the kind too obscene for public consumption.
I lick his tongue and he groans, loses his mind. Flattens me into the door, kisses me deep, hard, with my head braced against the surface behind me. My fingers find his hair. His slide down to my ass, grab two handfuls and tug me up and into him and I give a desperate whimper into his mouth. My skirt has bunched up in his palms, cool air hitting my ass, and he’s hard, so hard and pushing his cock against me with a grunt. Like he’s telling me See? This is what you do to me. This is what you’ve always done to me.
I come up for air and the low growling sound he makes tells me he isn’t one bit happy about it. His face falls to my neck and he licks a path of skin under my ear. Oh my God. I think—are we about to—
“Finn—”
My lungs reject the renewed airflow and I think he senses that because he cuts it off, slicks his tongue on mine, draws away, nips my lip. Comes back in for more and my body rumbles with the force of his moan. Like this is so good, kissing me is so good it does it for him even more than it did to rub his cock into me. And it is good. It’s so good, I need more. I need him—
“Finn.” He blinks at me in rapid succession, like he’s lost his sight, and I kiss along his jaw. “I have a confession, too.”
“What?” The word comes out almost slurred, like he’s drunk off my mouth.
“I fuck on the first date.”
With a pained sound his forehead meets my shoulder. He’s panting like he’s just climbed ten flights of stairs, and he’s gearing up for another ten. “I do too.”
The words are barely out of his mouth before my hands fumble between us, finding his erection and stroking him hard through his jeans.
He moans, this deep, guttural sound, like this teeny tiny thing, the feel of my hand through denim, does it for him just as good as if he were sliding into me. He hikes my leg up around his hip. Runs a hand along my thigh, caressing the soft crease where my leg meets my body, before moving between us too. Our hands compete frantically for space, fighting over who gets to give and who gets to take. He wins. His thumb runs along my pussy, over the damp outside of my panties and he grunts into my shoulder.
“Fuck, I love how wet you get. Tell me it’s just for me. Tell me all these fuckers who’ve had the God-given privilege of touching you didn’t do it for you like I do. Tell me they had to work twice as hard to get you ready, that the way you’re shaking right now only happens when it’s my cock about to fuck you senseless against this door.”
He doubles his grip around my waist when my legs give a violent shake that almost has me tipping over.
“It’s you, Finn. It’s you, it’s you—”
It’s not a lie, either. He doubles his pressure where he rubs me, and I’m sure that if he let go of me, if he stopped carrying my weight, I’d land face down in this carpeted hallway. I find his lips again, needing him to help stifle my moans. He toys with the edge of my panties.
And that’s the exact moment at which the woman in apartment 511 sticks her head out of her door.
“Hey, buddy,” she snaps, and with visible difficulty Finn turns to her, blinking rapidly in her direction as though trying to re-populate his line of sight. She’s looking right at us, glaring at the jumble of limbs we’ve become against his front door. “Do us all a favor and screw her inside your apartment.”
And she slams her door.
We stare in silent shock at the spot where her head disappeared. And then Finn swears under his breath and I burst into laughter against his neck.
Finn pulls back to look at me wryly. “I’m glad you find this funny.”
“You have to admit she has a point.”
But he looks stricken as he lowers my leg and extricates his fingers from where they’d just started pulling at my panties. He rubs the back of his neck, and with a loud exhale moves to plant his palms into his eyes, from under his glasses.
“Goddamn it.”
“Hey, it’s okay,” I tell him. “We’ll just take this inside. She’ll get over it eventually.”