“I don’t… I’m sorry. I don’t understand.”
I don’t even know what I’m referring to at this point. My mind is a hurricane.
It’s not a crush.
Of course it’s not a crush, you idiot. Everyone’s been trying to tell you.
Am I… What does it feel like to be in love?
Suddenly, I’m exhausted. My body feels like it weighs more than I’m capable of carrying. I think she can tell. I don’t realize I’ve backed into the wall until Jenna moves to pull me off it and leads me into my bedroom. She maneuvers me so that I sit on the edge of the bed, standing just out of reach.
Look at her. Of course it’s not just a crush. How could it be?
She laid herself bare for me tonight and all I returned was an emotional meltdown. Still, she’s not shuffling her feet, not clasping her hands together. She looks me right in the eye.
She’s a badass.
She’s a woman who maybe—fucking finally—understands how incredible she is. How capable she is. How much she deserves.
“I have feelings for you,” Jenna tells me again. “What you said to me, Finn? What you feel when I laugh or… Or when I make that slurping sound I really wish you pointed out before now, because I had no idea I did that, and it’s really kind of gross—” She breathes out a laugh and despite my catatonic state I hear one slip from my lips, too. “Maybe you’re not ready to accept what that feeling is, or what it means. But I love the way we are, and I want it for real. I want the titles. I want the white picket fence with you. And I’m willing to wait until you’re ready.”
“What if I’m never ready?”
She smiles. Actually fucking smiles. This sweet one, free of accusation or resentment. “I’m going to choose to believe you will be. I’m going to choose to wait you out. You’re worth it.”
She takes my chin between her fingers, lifting my face, and I feel like an empty, starved man staring up at the god who can deliver me from this torment, waiting for salvation. And then she bends, puts a kiss on my forehead, and I’m fucking spiraling. A good kind of spiral. A bad kind of spiral. I don’t know anymore.
Am I awake?
She turns to go and I lunge, catching her by the wrist. “Stay. Stay with me. Sleep here.”
Without a word she finds herself a t-shirt in my dresser, and hands me a pair of sweats. We shed our clothes in silence without taking our eyes off each other. In a past life, I couldn’t get through something like this without the urge to pin her underneath me, but I don’t feel any of that. It doesn’t feel empty, though. It feels like seeing each other for the first time. Acknowledging the stuff we’ve kept tucked deep.
She has feelings for me. Big ones that won’t go away.
Mine won’t pass. That’s the truth, isn’t it? They’re here to stay. What do I do with them?
In the dark, I let my hand wander across the mattress until it finds hers.
“Jenna,” I barely recognize my own voice.
She squeezes my hand. “Yeah?”
“You make it really hard, sometimes. Convincing myself I can live without you.”
She doesn’t say anything. She moves, shuffles around until she’s tucked herself against me, her back to my chest. And sleep finds me in an instant.
Chapter 18
Finn
I squeeze my eyes against the morning light, willing myself to fall back asleep.
To pass out until tomorrow, skip this day in its entirety. To be able to stay like this, with Jenna. The small spoon to my big spoon, letting me squeeze her to me like I’m trying to absorb her into my body.
I want to turn her over and set my eyes on her sweet face. But I don’t dare move. I want to keep her asleep, avoid that moment she’ll inevitably have when her eyes open, and she remembers how bad I let her down last night. How much I must have hurt her. I’d deserve it if she tried to sneak out of here, thinking I’m asleep. I’d only have myself to blame if she packed up her room, moved out of our home, and never gave me the time of day again. I wouldn’t blame her one bit.
I think I lost her last night. Never thought today could get any worse. Mom would have given me so much shit for leaving her hanging like that.