“It’s okay,” I say quietly, shaking my head when she makes a move toward me. She sits on her hands, like that’s how bad the urge is to touch me. “I’m not telling you this for sympathy. It was… They were the best role models for love I could have asked for, you know? They fought a lot, don’t get me wrong. I can’t tell you how many times I watched them both screw up, say or do the wrong thing. But they always fought like they knew it didn’t really matter. That their love was this ultimate, untouchable thing. And that no matter how bad they fucked up, it wouldn’t change a thing between them. It was that way until my mom died.”
“And you don’t think you can find that?”
“That’s the thing. Seeing everything that comes with it—the joy but the pain, too—it can make you realize it’s not the right life for you.”
I’m not sure any of that made sense. But Jenna looks at me like I’ve dropped all the answers in her lap, anyway. “You don’t think you’ll get lonely?”
Does she ever picture it? That alternate universe where we’re something we’re not? It’s a nice one. I never feel lonely when I’m there.
“I do feel that way sometimes. Did feel that way. Until I got a roommate,” I admit with a smile. “That’s why I need you to find a guy who can stand having me around. Promise me I get vetting privileges. I’ll find you that hot stud with enough money to buy you a nice big castle with a guest house that I’ll beg you to live in, and you’ll have to say yes because I’ll have been the one to introduce you. It’s my big master plan, see?”
Her mouth pinches into a tight smile. “Your big master plan is marrying me off to someone else?”
“You want to be married; I’ll make it happen.” The words feel like shattered glass coming out of my mouth. “That’s how this works, Jenna Bear. Don’t think I haven’t noticed this leash you somehow managed to get on me.” I pretend to tug at a collar around my neck.
The joke doesn’t land. That lackluster smile fades off her face. “And what if that’s not what I want?”
“You just said you wanted to be married—”
“What if I don’t want someone else?”
The burning in my throat has reached unbearable levels. I take a second to try to swallow it down. And another second, when it doesn’t work. Jenna’s cheeks are flaming red and I think I might be missing something.
“I don’t… I’m not sure where you’re going with this.”
“Aren’t you?”
I shake my head. I don’t even register that we’re staring at each other until her expression starts to morph. It goes from soft to something hard. Determined. There’s a pep talk going on in her head, and I wish she’d voice the words so that I could help her with it, whatever she’s working through.
Seems she doesn’t need me. She moves to sit on her knees. Squares her shoulders. “I need to ask you about something.”
There’s a prickle at the back of my neck, and the hairs on my arms rise. Something’s happening here, but I can’t put my finger on it, so I say: “Anything.”
Jenna sucks in a breath. “The forehead kisses. What are they about?”
“You don’t like them?”
“I love them.” She takes in the color in my cheeks. “What do they mean?”
My stomach drops. “It’s a friendly greeting between friends.”
Jenna contemplates me. “I don’t believe you.”
I stare back silently. Is this what it feels like? To have the gavel come down, declaring you guilty of all the sins you’ve ever tried to cover?
Jenna looks at me like she’s seeing something I can’t. Like it’s something she’s been searching for, and there it is. Finally.
“Jenna, I’m not sure what’s going on—”
“I need to tell you something.”
Suddenly I’m freezing cold. Whatever this is, it can’t be good. Why else would she be looking at me like that, like she’s expecting me to self-combust? I scan her from head to toe, looking for an answer. And just as the anticipation starts to kill me, she opens her mouth.
“Finn, I’m… I have feelings for you,” she confesses in a rush.
Oh, thank God.
My relief is so intense I laugh, almost falling back flat on the hardwood. “Oh. That. You just scared the shit out of me, Jenna Bear. Honestly, thanks for bringing this up. This weird crush thing has been eating away at me for ages too, and I haven’t been able to figure out how to squash it. But two heads are better than one, right? What are you thinking? How do we fix it?”