Page List

Font Size:

Finn stares down at me for a long moment, so still I don’t think he’s breathing. Then he fiddles with his glasses, pushing them up his nose. “Would you sleep in my bed tonight?”

There’s something so vulnerable in the way he says it. A piece of my heart chips away.

“Okay,” I tell him.

“All night this time?”

Another chip. I stand, comb my fingers through his hair. His eyelids drop, in the way a cat might sink into an embrace.

“All night this time.”

Chapter 17

Finn

Mrs. Jenkins from apartment 511 gives me a look as she unlocks her door.

It takes me a second to realize why: I seem to be whistling what I determine to be a Metallica song, which isn’t really whistling down the hall material. I also don’t know when it is I became someone who whistles in the first place. At my door, I adjust my hat and scratch at a dried-up dribble of sauce on my shirt.

It’s past midnight. I’m about to head into my own apartment, and there isn’t a single good reason I should care how I look.

Inside, Jenna sings along with the Smashing Pumpkins so loud I can hear every single word from out here. Something searing hot rises in my throat, and I swallow it down. Weird.

“Hey, Jenna Bear,” I call into the apartment, toeing off my sneakers.

The music is so loud she doesn’t hear me, and when I emerge into the living room I’m greeted to the sight of her cross-legged on the floor. There’s no nonsense from yesterday. She’s herself again in the pink spandex shorts she likes to wear, hair down, brushing over the shirt with my last name splashed across the back.

I don’t know what possessed me to give her that shirt. But it felt right, in the aftermath of what we did.

God, last night.

It’s strange. I’ve done a lot more, with a whole lot of women. But none of that felt the way it did last night. That? It wasn’t fucking, or fingering, or whatever the hell someone might call it. It felt like coming into a whole new plane of existence. Where all that mattered was giving her what she needed. I just wanted her to feel good. Physically, but about herself too. And I know it was a mistake, letting her touch me. I know it’ll make this crush that much harder to get over. But it wasn’t in me to hold back.

“Jenna,” I try again, only a little louder.

She still doesn’t hear me, so I let myself soak her in openly. In an alternate world, I’d walk right into our living room, bring her to her feet, and sink into the kind of kiss that would levitate us to a layer of the atmosphere not yet known to mankind. I’d pull her onto that sofa and spoon her so tight she’d think I was nuts. And I’d be able to admit to her that I am a little nuts, at least when it comes to her. Whenever she gives me that single dimple I feel the sanity seep right out of me. But in that alternate universe Mom would be alive, Dad wouldn’t be a broken man taped up with grief, and we’d be heading to see them for brunch in the morning.

As if sensing my attention Jenna turns, chin grazing her shoulder. And there it is. That dimple, beckoning me closer as she cuts the music.

“You’re home,” she says. She seems to be surrounded by a strange sea of tiny white boxes and ribbon I didn’t notice until now, and she pushes it all out of the way to make room for me.

I cup her cheek and bring her in for a forehead kiss. “I’m home. What’s all this?”

“These got delivered on your doorstep a couple hours ago, shortly followed by a phone call from Ronnie asking if I could help put together her wedding favors, as though I could easily figure out how to return all this stuff and say no.”

I swear, I’ve developed PTSD from hearing her sister’s name. Unfamiliar rage immediately starts boiling in my stomach whenever she says it. I sink to the ground and pick up what I realize is a piece of individually wrapped chocolate, with…

I squint down at the square. “Is that…”

Jenna drops some chocolate into a miniature white box. “My sister’s face? Yes.”

“And is that…”

She sticks a lid over the box and tops it with a neat little bow. “A much smaller version of my future brother-in-law’s face? Yes.”

I wrinkle my nose. “Why is it we’re making these? Don’t you all have enough money to have these done for you?”

She gives a little smile. “We do. The only reason I can come up with is that it’s been a solid couple of weeks since Ronnie adequately tortured me. She didn’t bother to explain, obviously.”


Novels you may like ...