Finn looks up and maybe I should feel embarrassed by the kind of moan the eye contact gets out of me, but I don’t.
“Can you come like this, Jenna?” he murmurs over my skin. He runs soft lips on the side of my breast, licking underneath it before moving to the other one.
“Not—” I swallow, trying to form the words. “Not usually. But Finn, I need you to—I really, really need—”
“Tell me.” His voice is thick. Suddenly urgent. Eyes greedy. “Tell me what you want, Jenna.”
I trail my hand down between our bodies, showing him where I need him to be.
Blue eyes meet mine. “Say it. You have to say it. Because right now, my brain’s screaming at me to quit before we cross another line. And I really need you to overrule it. Tell me what you want from me and I’ll give it to you.”
I pant. God, the things I want from him… But he has to be the one to choose to fuck me. I won’t push him into it.
“Put your fingers in me. Touch me. Make me come.”
His shoulders sag in relief. I let him pull my hand away from my pussy, push it into the hardwood in a non-verbal command, keep it here. His gaze flicks up to watch me as he slides his fingers over my clit.
“Like this?”
He just let me glimpse it. The reason women line up to have him. Finn doesn’t touch me with arrogance, like he already knows exactly what I like, how to give it to me. He wants to give me what I want. How I like it, how I want to take it.
He trails wet kisses up my body—my chest, over my shoulder, along my neck. He hovers with his face over mine, and studies every shift in me as he makes perfect little circles with his fingers on my clit. Pushing down when I tell him harder, and speeding up when I tell him more, I need more. And then dialing it back just when it starts to feel too much, without hearing me say so.
“Please,” the word bursts from my lips. “Please—Finn, please—”
I don’t even know, exactly, what I’m begging for. But Finn seems to be about a hundred steps ahead of me because his fingers slide lower. He groans as he slips inside me, twisting his fingers, pushing down, adding a finger, filling me up.
“Fuck, Jenna,” he says, teeth clenched, brows twisting. He drives his fingers in and out of me, tantalizingly slow. “You have no idea how long I’ve wanted you like this. You have no idea how good this feels.”
“I’m not even… You’re not even—” In the back of my mind I know I should be reaching for him. Doing anything to him. I give a feeble attempt at reaching for his cock, still buried in his jeans, but then his fingers hit me with more pressure as he drags them inside me and I— “There,” I choke out, feeling almost delirious with pleasure. “Like that. Please, Finn. Please make me come—”
And now that he’s figured it out, he doesn’t stop. Pushing his fingers in and out of my pussy in slow, shallow strokes. Both my hands are tangled in his hair, and I feel it starting, that tremor deep inside. He must feel it around his fingers because he shifts back onto his heels and puts his other hand to work. Thumb grazing my clit in that perfect way, just like I asked, and everything blurs around me as pleasure rises my spine. My hips start moving and he lets me set the pace as I start fucking his hand.
“Ohmygodfinn.” It comes out like a single, slurred word. “Feels so good.”
“For me too.” With heavy lids, he watches the way his fingers move over me, in me. “I love feeling you. I love your body. Those sounds, Jenna. Your fucking sounds—”
I moan. It’s the way he’s touching me, but it’s the words too. It’s him. “Come here. Come closer.”
He leaves his fingers inside me, fucking me in the same rhythm my hips moved before they stilled underneath him. He reaches for one of my hands and brings it down to my clit, watching as I take over rubbing myself before planting his hand by my head so that he hovers over me.
I can’t pinpoint the exact moment something heavy settles in my lungs. But it’s there now as I gaze at him. I take in the hunger in his eyes and the soft smile he gives me like he’s having a moment too as he touches me, even though I’m not touching him. Finn dips to kiss my forehead and gives a hum of encouragement against my skin when I let out a tight whimper, until finally I shatter. Burst into tiny fragments that land in a heaping, disheveled pile on the floor. He keeps up his effort all the way through my orgasm, letting me shake into his hand, clench around his fingers until finally I’m limp, made of nothing but skin and air.
“You look so fucking incredible when you come,” he mutters, kissing my neck as I gasp desperately for air. He combs flyaway hairs back with his free hand, the other still fucking me but slowing down its strokes as I start to come together again, vision starts to come back into focus. “I’d give up everything to do this for you every minute of the day. To make you feel this good and get those sweet little sounds out of you.”
His fingers keep pumping into me, soft and soothing, giving me a point of focus as I try to regain myself. I’m still trying to take a single calm breath. My head is a jumbled mess of words, and all I can do is move between us, grappling with the waistband of his jeans.
Finn stops me, pulling my hands away. Still thrusting gently into me and I wonder now whether it’s a tactic to keep me useless, boneless beneath him. I give a weak moan.
“Don’t worry about me. I want you to come again, baby. Can you do that for me?”
I want to, badly. But there’s one single thing I want more right now.
I want his body, yes. But more than anything I need to feel closer to him. To have him open himself up and stop holding back from me. Taking a deep, calming breath, I reach for his wrist and pull the length of his fingers out of my pussy. God, even that. Even that felt unbelievably good. So good I slide him back in, once, twice, whimpering desperately as I pull him right out. I push him upright by the shoulders, and meet him on his knees. He slips the fingers he’d just had inside me into his mouth as he watches me unclasp the bra he’d slid down, pull up the panties still around my thighs.
“If you tell me you don’t want it, I will let this go in a second,” I tell him, and he swallows heavily. “And it’s not about returning favors or feeling like I owe you one. I want to touch you. To make you feel as good as you make me feel.”
Finn closes his eyes, lets out a sharp breath. “What are you doing to me, Jenna?”