“Is this some weird attempt at practicing for your sister’s wedding? It’s definitely not the kind of role play I’m into, and the least you could have done was prep me on my character. At this point, the best I can do for you is Finnigan, the unwieldy wedding guest no one wanted to invite, except that I happen to be Aunt Henrietta’s only kid and she’d have Ronnie’s head on a spike if I weren’t on the list.”
“I don’t have an Aunt Henrietta,” I say, dropping back into my seat and cutting neatly through my slice of Wellington.
“Fortunately,” he continues like he didn’t hear me. “They’ve sat me in the corner and out of the way with our cousin Flavius, the failed politician who resigned in disgrace after confessing that he used your grandmother’s inheritance to fund a mission to prove the earth was sucked into a black hole in 2012.”
I blink. Finn blinks.
I’m trying not to laugh. He’s waiting for me to lose that battle.
“According to Cousin Flavius,” he goes on. “We’ve all been dead for eleven years. Only no one’s noticed yet. Except him, of course.”
The bite of Wellington hovers inches from my mouth. I curl my lips into my mouth and bite down hard to stifle my laugh.
“I like to think I would have noticed if I was dead,” he says solemnly. He lets his eyes wander the length of the table between us. “Though I’m starting to think he might be onto something. This has to be some kind of weird death-dream, doesn’t it? Jenna Carling in a turtleneck, sitting five feet away from me. Even if we aren’t dead, I’m not quite sure I want to live in a world where Jenna Fucking Carling wears a strange turtleneck she felt the need to buy five minutes ago.”
My stomach flips. He says Jenna Fucking Carling like he’s talking about someone else. Some ancient mythical goddess, honored around the world with shrines and monuments.
I swallow, smoothing down the front of my shirt. “Jenna Fucking Carling has owned this turtleneck for years. Jenna Fucking Carling loves this turtleneck. It suits her.”
“It’s true. Everything suits Jenna Fucking Carling. But you have to admit it’s reasonable that your sudden propensity for turtlenecks would raise a couple eyebrows.”
“I’ve had this turtleneck for years.”
He hums, contemplating me. “You won’t mind it getting a little bit messy, then.”
“Messy?”
With a slow blink and an innocent smile he slides a piece of phyllo dough off his plate and onto the table, and lines up his fingers behind it in a flicking position.
My eyes saucer. “You wouldn’t.”
He offers me the full breadth of his crooked smile. “Have you met me? Of course, I would. Now tell me what’s going on with you, or this here piece of pastry will be the first in a long line of things making a mess of you tonight.”
“Jenna Fucking Carling is impervious to mess—”
The piece of food hits me square in the chest in an explosion of crumbs. I stare down at myself, jaw dropping. “You wouldn’t survive a second at a Carling family dinner—”
Splat.
This time, the piece of food carried a healthy serving of gravy that splatters all the way up to my chin.
“The day I survive a Carling family dinner is the day you’ll know to check me into a wellness facility. And the day you survive one? Babe, that’ll be the day I pack you up and ship us both to the other side of the world, until we’ve got enough time and miles between us and that insane family of yours for you to remember how much better off you are as the black sheep.”
“Maybe I’ve decided I don’t want to be the black sheep anymore.” I go to flick my hair over my shoulder, only to brush away air as it sits in a tight bun on top of my head.
Finn watches the failed attempt with a tilt of his head. “Take that fucking hair tie out, or so help me God.”
I lift my chin. “Or so help you God what, Finn?”
“Or so help me God, I’ll take matters into my own hands.” He gestures to the top of his head. “With the hair bun and that turtleneck. And don’t even get me started on that damn skirt.” He peers under the table and resurfaces, utterly scandalized. “Where have your legs gone?”
“Are you threatening to strip me down?”
That wasn’t exactly lady-like. My mother would wither away if she ever heard me say something like that over dinner. But Finn’s eyes flick to mine. And I watch it happen, watch the way heat cuts through play, the way his body stills. Like now that he thinks about it, now that I suggested it, there’s nothing he’d rather do.
Finn rises with a slowly growing smile, so different than the playful ones he’d lobbed at me over the course of this disastrous dinner.
“Up,” he says simply.