He moves slowly, giving me enough room to plop down beside him. Tentatively, I reach for his hand under the table. He’d held mine earlier, out in the street, despite the way he clammed up when I took his hand the morning he looked after me and my cramps. And if he only wants to hold hands on his terms that’s okay. As long as he knows how grateful I am for him. How hard I’d work to bring up his mood, too.
Finn drops his chin. He stares at our fingers as they interconnect, swallowing heavily, shoulders reaching for his ears. Lower lashes brushing the skin under his eyes. The bell chimes over the bake shop door, from somewhere to our left.
“Jenna.”
It’s all he says, voice barely above a whisper. Brows crinkled like he doesn’t even know the end of his own sentence. His eyes close.
And then he lets go of my hand, moving so swiftly I barely have a moment to feel the pang of disappointment before he runs his arm behind me, snaking it around my waist, and tucks me into his side. He squeezes until I sink into him, cheek hitting his warm shoulder. He smells like he does every night after work. Fresh laundry and a concoction of delicious spices from standing in the kitchen. I breathe him in.
“Want another story?” His voice is soft. He fixes his gaze on the leftover Frankencake sitting on its side in the lid of one of the pastry boxes.
“Yeah. I want another story.”
My chest feels heavy. It’s painful, like I’m seconds away from a sob. But it’s also kind of warm. This feeling like I’ve got a laugh trapped at the base of my throat that can’t decide whether to come out.
“Did I ever tell you about the one and only time I tried using a fake ID?”
“Tell me.”
He lets his head rest against the back of the bench. “I was sixteen and a total shit-head—”
“Shocker.”
A grin breaks over his face, dislodging the discomfort there. “Seriously. My parents were saints, between the hell Hayley and I would put them through. I went through a phase where I would sneak out the window in my room at night. And on this night in question, I was going to meet up with my buddies to try out our new fake IDs. And so I’ve got one leg out of my window, ready to climb down, when my bedroom door blows open with my mom on the other side.”
“Oops.”
“Oops,” he agrees with a nod. “So, we sit there in this stand-off. Staring at each other, not saying a word. And I could tell she was steaming on the inside—she was white-knuckling my doorknob, you know? I could see it from where I was, hanging out of the window. But after a minute she gives me this funny look. Backs out of the room and shuts the door. And I think… Shit. She’s really letting me off the hook? And I start feeling guilty about it, but then the guys pull up in their car and I head out anyway.”
I sink deeper into his body as he speaks, comforted by the sound of his voice. Just loving the way he connects dots within a story.
“And I’m a total idiot at that age—did I say that already? Yeah, I think I did. So obviously I get drunk even before we make it out to the bar. And these IDs, they were so bad. I don’t know what we were thinking. The whole blond hair, blue eyes thing I have going on made me look about five years younger than I was back then, too. Obviously, the bartender doesn’t buy it for a second. And so security starts walking me out, and I trip on the threshold leaving the bar. Fall flat on my face and smash my nose up. Blood everywhere.”
I give a shocked laugh. “This started off so upbeat.”
Finn’s crooked smile takes over his entire face. “It’ll come back around, don’t worry.” He points at the subtle bump on the bridge of his nose. “See that? They could never really set it properly. But I’m getting ahead of myself. So, I’m panicking, refuse to go to the hospital, right? And I make it back home and when my damn nose still won’t stop bleeding, I wake up my parents.” His whole body stills in that moment, gaze drifting in a faraway stare. A little wistful, like he’s back there in his parents’ bedroom. He swallows heavily, collecting himself. “My dad starts flying off the handle when he sees me. But Mom puts a hand on his arm. Tells him to stop, to go back to bed. And then… she gives me this kiss on my forehead. Gets me in the car and takes me to the hospital. Never yelled. Never asked what I’d been up to, nothing. Just got me fixed up and took me back home.”
I curl my lips into my mouth and bite down. It has to be a little sick. That I envy him for a mother he no longer has, instead of feeling that way about the mother I still have around.
“I never really understood why she didn’t give me grief over it. But I never snuck out again.”
“She got you good, huh?”
He gives a low laugh, and every single note of it sinks into my skin. It was just a small dose. A tiny high. Instantly, I crave more of it.
“She got me good. Parental guilt is a hell of a thing,” he agrees. After a small pause he adds: “It’s almost the anniversary. Of the day she died.”
“Finn…”
Before I can finish, Finn plasters a wide smile on his face that doesn’t quite reach his eyes. “Sorry. I’m killing the mood. Probably not what you needed from me, huh? After the night you’ve had.”
Sweet Finn.
“You didn’t kill the mood. This is what it is to get close to someone. You share, and it gets heavy sometimes.”
“It feels weird,” he mutters, looking out over the other side of our booth at the purple wall framing the front windows of the shop.
“What, you never had pillow talk with any of your girls?”