I comb through my ponytail with my fingers, willing away the stinging in my eyes.
One day, you’ll meet a man who won’t care for that thing you have between your legs. And you won’t have a thing to offer him.
Ronnie warned me.
“I almost forgot. I got you something.” Finn clears his throat from the kitchen. I fist my hands, letting my pink fingernails dig into my skin. He gestures to a sunshine yellow box on the counter. “Are these the ones?”
I squint in his direction, trying to make out what he means. And then I recognize the box.
“Oh, Finn,” I gasp, moving quickly to meet him. “This is where you went earlier?”
“Well… yeah,” he says, like it’s the most obvious thing in the world.
He watches me flip open the box to reveal six perfect cupcakes—fluffy white frosting swirling inches high with bits of crispy caramel sprinkled on top. I’ve been raving about these for days. Before I went away, they were the ultimate pick-me-up whenever I’d come home from a visit with my parents or crossed paths with Ronnie.
“You drove all the way across town during rush hour just to get these for me?”
He rubs the back of his neck, a pale flush creeping up his neck. “Yeah, I… I overheard your phone call earlier. You sounded really down. Seriously, what the hell is your sister’s problem?”
“Now that’s a mystery worthy of a Planet Network special.”
Truly. Somehow, an offer to help book the limo for Ronnie’s bachelorette party turned into an hour-long lecture about an outfit I hadn’t even decided to wear to it.
I stare at Finn, trying to understand.
I don’t think a man has ever caught me more off-guard. He’s… considerate. Attentive and… Respectful. Definitely different from what I’ve become used to in recent years. Even my ex never did this kind of thing for me, and we’d been together for ages.
It’s weird.
I don’t understand why Finn’s trying so hard. I already agreed to sleep with him.
What’s your game, Finn Palmer?
“Are they the right ones?” Finn looks so suddenly anxious my heart pinches. I force my confusion aside.
“Definitely the right ones. I can’t believe you did this.”
He dips his chin. Without the typical backwards hat on, sandy strands fall into his face. Finn reaches for a cupcake and carefully hands it to me. “How’d you find this place?”
“I lived in the condo building next door. The nutritional value of my diet plummeted after I discovered these ones in particular.” I groan into a massive, messy bite that gets frosting all over my mouth. “There’s no way to eat these gracefully, by the way. It’s part of their magic.”
The frosting is all over my face, covering my top lip and clumping over my chin. I hand Finn the cupcake, freeing myself up to wipe my chin, the tip of my nose. I lick at the smear of vanilla on my mouth. In my peripheral vision, I see the cupcake go down on the counter, still in Finn’s hand but compressing strangely so that the small tower of frosting starts to lean to one side. And suddenly the entire cupcake bursts, cake and frosting pooling over his entire closed fist.
When I look up, he’s staring at me with such intensity his jaw pulses, eyes so hard he almost looks furious. I lick off the corner of my mouth, about to ask him what gives, when I realize it. He’s staring at the way I’m licking my lips.
“You know, your signals are more mixed than a tape in the nineties.”
He doesn’t seem to hear me.
Is this all I needed? A little vanilla and caramel to make myself appealing?
With my thumb, I brush the edge of my lower lip and lick off the icing I collected with the flat of my tongue. He runs his tongue along the outline of his own lip as though wishing for traces of vanilla.
Relief pools in my chest. He does want me. He does.
His hand still holds the destroyed cupcake in a death grip. I take his fist, pry the cake free and lift his hand. Take a finger in my mouth, letting the velvety frosting coat my tongue as I slide it out. I do it again with his next finger. And the one after that.
Finn’s mouth has popped open. It tastes so good, that creamy and caramel flavor mixing with his, and I crave more of it. I place an open kiss on the last, tiny fleck of icing on his skin.