“No. No. Absolutely not.”
He rubs his face. “But… that night. At the hotel. Not even then?”
My stomach clenches. “If you’re asking whether I slept with you – or whatever that was – for a promotion –”
“No,” he says quickly, loudly, every line on his face horrified at the mere suggestion. “Not at all. I meant earlier, at dinner. And on the drive there, after we argued. Not even then? It was like a switch flipped. One second you couldn’t look at me, and the next we’re getting along.”
I feel sick. “You think I would do something like that?”
The look on his face tells me he feels it too, the rolling nausea in his stomach. “Please. Just answer the question.”
“Theo, that had nothing to do with the promotion. Nothing. It was never going to be sustainable, living another month at each other’s throats. So, yes, I made a conscious decision to back off for the sake of the project. But everything after that – I wanted to be around you, for you. Wanted to be with you, for you.”
Theo stares at the hands in his lap as though they’re not his. “Then why wouldn’t you tell me?”
I shrug helplessly. “I don’t know. I mean, it’s not typical to tell a client you have a promotion hinging on their project.”
Instantly, I know I’ve said the wrong thing. Theo looks like I’ve slapped him clean across the face.
“Please don’t do that to me,” he says quietly. “Don’t reduce me to a client, after everything. It’s hard enough keeping the faith that this thing is real with as little as you give me.”
And there it is.
The insecurity I’ve felt since Friday solidifying into reality. I haven’t told him I love him, haven’t reciprocated the words, and as understanding as he is, it still gets to him. And of course, it does. Who wouldn’t be bothered by it? Being as open and raw as he’s been, with someone too emotionally stunted to give some of it back?
“I’m sorry –”
“Don’t apologize. I know it doesn’t come easy for you and I went into this with eyes wide open. I’m not asking for you to suddenly pour your heart out. All I’m asking is that you don’t walk back whatever progress we’ve managed to make.”
There isn’t a speck of accusation in his expression. He looks at me the way he always does, as though I’ve hung the moon for him and him alone to admire.
And that’s what breaks me.
He doesn’t deserve this – the way I can only muster one foot into the doorway of this relationship. A man like this deserves someone willing and able to take what he has to offer and to give it right back. I’ve known it, tried to fool myself into thinking it would be okay anyway. But what I’m giving him isn’t enough, and that isn’t okay. It’s the last thing I want for him.
“This had nothing to do with the promotion,” I say again, coaching my hands to stop trembling, my heart to stop aching. To shove it all in deep, the way I’ve become an expert at doing. Cut off the pain at the source before it’s too late and it spills right out.
“I believe you,” he tells me, without hesitation.
I take his hand. Squeeze it tight, needing to memorize how he feels, to absorb his fingerprints into my skin so that fifty years from now I still remember what it felt like, being loved by him. Like a buoy thrown to me in the middle of the raging sea. A lump rises in my throat, and I take a few seconds to swallow it down. At least until he leaves. Because he’d never go otherwise.
“I wish you didn’t,” I whisper, dropping his hand. “I wish you’d argue and yell and tell me how bad it hurt to hear Diana say that. I wish you’d berate me for giving you so little that it would even seem plausible that I might have been using you.”
“I don’t need you to say or do anything you aren’t ready for,” he says gently. “You’re enough like you are –”
“I’m not –”
“You are –”
“Okay, maybe I’m enough today. But tomorrow? Next week, month? How long can you go like this?”
“This isn’t a race. It takes time –”
“I’m not convinced I’ll ever be able to let go of my issues – it’s been years and I’m still a mess. I’m not convinced I’ll ever be able to let you in the way you deserve.”
He looks baffled, so genuinely confused by the shift in conversation that I almost balk. I feel like a wolf on the prowl, stalking a peaceful, unsuspecting nest of birds. But chickening out now will only hurt him later. He deserves so much more than the scared, broken thing I am.
I fold my fingers together so tightly they start to pale. “Theo, I need some time to myself.”