Ms Ellison stopped talking as my mate looked round to me with wide eyes. She didn’t need to be able to scent his panic to know that’s what he was doing.
I pulled him tighter against me, making sure he couldn’t run away. I didn’t want him running from me ever again.
“We know you left that secret Santa gift, love.”
“How do you know? It-it could have been anyone.”
I restrained a smile as my mate tried to bluster his way out of being caught, badly I might add.
“Because both Tony and I could smell your scent on the wrapping paper.”
From the other side of the large kitchen, Jo grinned. “Yeah, and I’ve spent all day watching re-runs of Paulo Slips Presents into People’s Desks Without Anyone Noticing. It’s a great show.”
The fight seemed to go out of Paulo and he sagged. “Are you mad about it?”
Jo shook her head. “Hell no. I’m impressed. You have some serious sneaking skills, Paulo. And you got me my first tattoo.”
The effect of her words was instantaneous. Paulo lit up. There was no better word to describe it.
He stepped forward and asked eagerly, “Did you get it? What does it look like?”
“Want to see?”
Paulo nodded and Jo was already yanking her t-shirt over her head and turning her back towards us so we could see.
“It’s incredible,” breathed Paulo. “Do you like it?”
Jo gave him a wink over her shoulder. “It’s my favourite.”
I asked what I presume was on everyone’s mind. “What made you get Jo a tattoo? She’d never told us she wanted one.”
Paulo gave a shrug, gesturing at her body as she yanked her t-shirt back into place and faced us again. “I just thought… someone as hot as her should have ink to decorate her skin.”
Jo threw back her head and laughed at my chagrin that my mate thought someone else was hot. Paulo tried to explain. “I mean it purely objectively; I’m gay.”
Joe folded his arms. “So what do I have to do to get on the Nice List, then? Because it looks like everyone is getting their best presents except me.”
Paulo shuffled from foot to foot and his scent changed to uncertainty.
“What is it, love?”
“Oh, um, well, it’s just… I suppose if you know it’s me, there’s no point in hiding this, is there? You can have it now.”
Paulo pulled out the piece of paper from his pocket and held it out to Joe.
“Sorry it’s a bit crumpled. That fox shifter crushed it a bit when he grabbed me. I was going to make it look all nice and Christmassy, honest.”
Joe’s eyebrows went up. “This is for me?”
“Yes. I hope you like it.”
Joe took the paper and unfolded it like he expected it to explode or something. I leaned forward, wanting to know what it was. Somehow, Paulo was able to identify things inside of people that I couldn’t see. I wanted to know what Joe’s heart was.
He gave an entirely disappointing, “Cool, thanks.”
“Don’t you like it?” I asked.
“Yeah, it’s great.”