Our conversation shifted to our hobbies and interests, and it was like not much had really changed from the old versions of us, but things had been added to enhance us. Neptune still loved spending time with family, sports, and reading. I thought it was pretty cute that he and Merci had their own little two-person book club and often went to expos and events together. Now he loved pool and traveling and often did both with his brother.
I shared with him that I still loved watching movies, skating, and bowling. Now I was a gamer too. Specifically, Call of Duty. Back home, I would play for hours. That was why I didn’t even bother with bringing my game.
We were both still active, and we spent the last of our picnic talking about the recreational things we could do like rock climbing, tennis, and pickle ball. He told me about his father’s membership at a country club and how he’d get me a pass so I could come with him to play. By the time we left our hideaway spot, I was even more convinced I needed to stay home and rebuild my life here. But in order for me to do that, I had to come completely clean; otherwise, withholding the truth about the abortion was going to eat me alive.
“Thank you for coming to see about me,” I said as Neptune parked in Franko’s driveway. I would probably chat with them for a little while before going to my parents’ home tonight. The night nurse would be here soon, and with her help, they wouldn’t need me.
“You know I got you always, bae. No question about it.”
Licking the corner of my mouth, I swallowed down my nerves and decided to just get it over with. If we were going on our first adult date tomorrow, that would be the start of our new beginning. I couldn’t pull the past back up after that.
“There was a reason I acted so crazy that night,” I blurted as Neptune unbuckled his seat belt.
“I figured there was.”
“Why didn’t you try and figure it out?”
Neptune shrugged. “I felt like you’d tell me if I needed to know. I knew you were off. It wasn’t that I didn’t care enough to figure out why. I just focused on providing what I thought was the best solution regardless of what the real problem actually was. With time and maturity, I’ve learned that wasn’t the best way to handle that situation, but it is what it is now.”
“I was pregnant, Neptune,” I almost whispered, but I knew he heard me because his head jerked in my direction as he scowled. All my nervous energy went to my hands as I rubbed them together. “When our parents found out we were having sex, and they sat us down to talk about the consequences of kids making adult decisions, you said if I was to get pregnant, you’d marry me.” My eyes watered immediately as his shoulders sagged. “I didn’t want you to marry me just for the baby though. So, I told myself if I mentioned marriage before I told you, that would be how I knew if you’d marry me for me.”
A soft, bitter laugh escaped me as he looked away, rolling his tongue over his cheek. “And I know that sounds immature, but I was about to severely adjust both of our lives, but especially mine. I’d have to push my first year of college back, I wouldn’t have been able to work, and we would have had to get married if our parents had anything to say about it. I just thought about all I’d have to give up and sacrifice having a baby, and a part of me needed to know you were going to choose me before you knew I was pregnant. I said I would bring it up three times before telling you I was pregnant. But the third time I mentioned marriage—”
“I broke up with you,” he added, voice detached as he stared at the moon.
“Yeah.” Clearing my throat, I squeezed the back of my neck. “And I get why. You didn’t want marriage ruining our futures. You wanted us to go to school, stick to our plans, all that jazz.”
“What did you do, Milani?”
“I was hurt,” I reasoned, needing to make it make sense before the words actually came out. “I was angry. I-I hated you. I felt like you didn’t want me, and if you didn’t want me, you didn’t want my baby. So I-I got an abortion. There was no way I could raise a baby alone in a different state, and I refused to stay home after you all but pushed me across city lines. I convinced myself the abortion was for the best so there would be nothing tying me to the man wh-who didn’t want to be with me anymore.”
His head slowly turned in my direction, eyes glossy when he confirmed, “You killed my baby?”
“I’m sorry. I felt like you’d killed our future, and I didn’t want to have our baby by myself.”
“You wouldn’t have been by yourself!” he yelled, causing me to jump as my tears finally fell. “You know I would have stepped up had I known about the baby.”
“Yeah, you would have asked me to marry you and fucked up our lives in the process, right? You didn’t want to marry me when it was just me, but it would have been okay for you to marry me for the sake of our child? What kind of marriage would that have been? Life would that have been?
“I needed to know how you really felt about me, and seeing as it was so easy for you to break up with me without even trying to talk about it and figure out why I was so adamant about marriage all of a sudden, I’d say I made the right call. Do I regret the abortion? Yes. More than anything else in my life. But this isn’t just my fault, Neptune. You gave up on me, on us, and that shit hurt me so much I gave up on our future. Our baby.”
“You need to get out,” he said, and I could tell by the dejected tone of his voice that he was about to give up on me.
Again.
Scoffing, I shook my head as he opened his door to walk around and open mine.
“Really, Neptune? You’re shutting down again? I’m calm and regulated. Can we please have an adult conversation this time around?”
Without verbally answering me, he placed a firm yet gentle grip on my arm and used it to lift me out the car. His voice was calm yet trembled when he said, “You killed my fucking baby, Lani. It really ain’t shit I have to say to you that would be nice right now.”
“And like always, you get to decide when we talk? You get to decide if we’re together or not.” I jerked away from him. “You get to control every-fucking-thing. Why did I think things would be different this time around?”
Ignoring me, he walked back to the driver’s side of the car and swerved out of the driveway.
I knew he hated fighting with me.
I knew he hated saying or doing the wrong thing when it came to me.