“Oh? And what else have you received?” I ask as I bite into one of the cookies that I know came from Lauren, but I won’t spoil the surprise for my sister. Cara rattles off the gifts she’s received so far as I enjoy the soft and sweet cookie, until an alarm bell starts going off in my gut.
“But what about a gift card? Didn’t you get one?” Lauren wasn’t sure if someone gave her the gift cards because of her car issues. She didn’t want to seem ungrateful by questioning it to the group—but she also admitted she felt like she could have stolen presents from her friends.
But I don’t think that’s what’s going on. Not that I know exactly what is going on. It doesn’t make sense.
Cara shrugs. “I didn’t, but maybe we are getting different gifts from some people? Like personalized ones?”
That doesn’t add up. Lauren’s received similar gifts to the other book club members, but she seems to also be getting additional gifts, and expensive ones at that. I file it away as my sister continues.
“Besides, I’m too busy this time of year to do that and honestly was just happy I could whip up those cookie mixes without much fuss.”
“Perk of a commercial baking kitchen,” Max chimes in playfully.
Cara gasps in mock outrage. “Hey, now. You know I did those right here.”
“My statement still stands.” Max raises an eyebrow and Cara laughs in response.
“Yeah, yeah, yeah, love you too,” she says as she leans over and kisses his cheek.
He preens like a proud peacock. “I know you do, baby.”
When they built this house, Cara wanted an insane kitchen—and that’s exactly what Max made sure she got.
If I were a betting man, and I can be occasionally, I think it’s a safe bet that Max will do whatever he can to ensure she gets exactly what she wants for the rest of her life.
And I know for a fact that she is going to lose her absolute mind when she sees the diamond-encrusted sapphire he is planning to use when he proposes to her on Christmas Eve.
Even I was stunned when I saw the piece he had custom ordered last week. He asked for my blessing as the only family Cara really has left—like I would ever say no to the guy. Not only does Max dote on my sister, but he also shows up for my kids and literally helped save their lives last year.
For the first time in a very, very long time, I allow myself to wonder if something like that could be in the cards for me.
And for the first time in just as long, it doesn’t seem impossible.
CHAPTER FIFTEEN
Jeff
Hey, Lauren. Phoebe mentioned that you were having car issues. Do you need a ride home today?
Me
Hi, Jeff. That’s so nice of you, but I actually got it up and running again. Thanks, though!
Jeff
Just let me know if you ever need a ride, happy to help out!
Me
That’s very kind of you. Thank you!
I slide my phone back into my pocket and resume staring at the box on my desk. I should leave it closed, but I can’t help how curious I am about this unexpected gift. Opening the box, I hold it in my hand, again stunned by what I’m seeing.
“Miss Davenport?” Dante’s timid voice startles me for some reason, and I snap the box shut and slip it into my top desk drawer. I should probably take it home, but something isn’t sitting right with me. This morning when I left for school, I found another gift on my front porch. It was once again wrapped in the same dark green festive wrapping paper with delicate watercolor-painted fir branches. I was running late and didn’t have time to open the gift until my brief lunch break.
And it’s a good thing I was sitting down.
As I untied the ivory ribbon and slid off the wrapping paper, I audibly gasped.