“To be honest … both. I wasn’t sure I was allowed to even want something like this after everything.”
She reaches across the table and takes my hand, and I quickly intertwine our fingers. “I bet it’s a lot of adjusting, a lot of new and familiar at the same time.” I nod at that as she softly squeezes my hand. “But for what it’s worth, I’m really glad you moved to Forrest Falls.”
“Me too, babe.” The term of endearment escapes without thought.
“Babe, huh?” She raises an eyebrow at me with a grin.
“Yeah, it, uh, it just came out. Is that … are you good with that?” Suddenly, it feels like the candles in this place are cranking out more heat than should be possible for tiny little tea lights.
She bites her lower lip and tilts her head before a small smile spreads across her beautiful face. “Yeah, I’ve never really been called babe before. It’s … it’s nice, Luca.” She squeezes my hand, and an audible exhale escapes my lungs.
Lauren doesn’t make a big deal of my relief, and the rest of dinner is just easy. Talking to Lauren is as easy as it was texting with her, but I get to hear her giggles, see her play with her hair, and smell the unique blend of cinnamon and vanilla that is either her body wash or perfume, but I doubt it would smell as good on anyone else. Before I know it, we are back at her house, and I’m opening the car door for her.
She slides her hand into my outstretched one, and I help her out of the car and hold on to her hand as we head up the short front walk to her charming little front porch. She has colorful Christmas lights wrapped around the porch railing, and a vintage light-up blow mold Santa tucked in the corner.
She turns to me with a hesitant smile. “Thank you for a lovely evening, Luca. I really enjoyed dinner and especially the company.” She steps closer, then pauses, looking up expectantly.
I let go of her hand to slide my hand around her back and pull her closer to me. My other hand slides up her jaw and cradles her face—and I don’t miss how she leans into my touch. “There isn’t any mistletoe out here tonight, so I want to be clear this is not out of tradition, but very much just because I want to kiss you.” I barely pause to angle her face to mine then claim her lips. I’m gentle at first, but when she bites my lower lip, I groan in surprise and want. “If I didn’t have my kids to pick up, I would ask if I could come inside, but I have to be honest, I think … I think this is going to be more than worth the wait,” I murmur against her lips, and she giggles in response.
“Yes, yes, the children, of course.” She winks—the little brat—and I love it. “But I agree, except for one detail.”
“What’s that?” I lean back to get a better look at her face.
She grins and points up to the archway over her porch—to the small sprig of mistletoe hanging over the threshold to her porch. I pull her in for a hug and wrap my arms around her as I laugh.
“To be fair, I didn’t see that. I promise!” I insist because I want her to know I didn’t kiss her out of obligation.
Her smile drops just a little, and her tone is softer as she responds. “I know, I just wanted to hedge my bets.”
“How so?”
She grins and leans forward up on her toes to whisper in my ear. “I hung that up this afternoon, just in case you walked me to my door.”
Well, damn. This woman is unlike anyone else I’ve ever met. I thought she was this innocent, sweet schoolteacher, and while that’s part of her, it’s definitely not all of her.
And I can’t wait to discover all of it.
CHAPTER ELEVEN
Pippa
Ladies, did I miss a memo? It started the other day with magical cookies showing up on my doorstep, and now it’s a signed paperback from my favorite author… who happens to have an editor that belongs to our book club. What is happening?
Willa
Dang it! I knew that was going to be too easy to guess which gift was mine.
Willa
I mean, maybe someone else just has great taste in authors!
Willa
Yeah, that one. Let’s go with that one.
Sophia
Willa… everyone on this chat has an iPhone. You could have just edited the text, girl lol.