Leah’s gaze drifted back to mine, that same unsettling recognition flickering behind her eyes. She was trying to place me. Trying to understand why her body responded to me like a threat her mind couldn’t identify.
I studied her face carefully, searching for any sign that she remembered, but there was only polite confusion.
She swallowed, glancing away before forcing a smile.
“Your home is beautiful.”
Ethan smiled. “Maybe it can be yours someday, too.”
I tensed.
He guided her away, glancing back at me once over his shoulder with that knowing grin I wanted to carve off his face.
I only smirked back, shaking my head. I took one final drag from my cigarette before throwing it to the ground and crushing it into the grass beneath my boot. I couldn’t understand why Ethan would go to this degree for fun.
He returned an hour later, long after some women he’d invited had pulled away Leah. She stood across the patio now, nursing what looked like a vodka cranberry and smiling politely at whatever Veronica was saying.
Her eyes kept finding mine across the distance between us, and each time, she looked away quickly.
But not quickly enough.
“So?” Ethan leaned against the tree beside me, his shoulder brushing mine. “What do you think?”
“About what?”
“Leah.” He smiled while watching her across the yard. “Thomas Matthews’s daughter. Pretty fucking poetic, don’t you think?”
The second cigarette I grabbed snapped between my fingers.
I let the pieces fall into the grass, grinding them beneath my boot.
“You knew,” I breathed.
Ethan’s smile widened. “Knew what?”
“Cut the shit, Ethan. You knew exactly who she was when you walked in here.”
He laughed, sharp and humorless.
“What the fuck are you thinking, dating her?” He shrugged, stealing a cigarette from my pack and sliding it between his lips. “James doesn’t know you’re fucking her,” I said.
It wasn’t a question.
Ethan’s smile faltered for half a second before recovering. He lit the cigarette and inhaled deeply before blowing smoke rings toward the pond.
“James doesn’t need to know every detail of my personal life.” He shrugged with indifference. “Besides, she has no idea who I really am. Who we really are. To her, I’m just a businessman who loves books.”
I kept my face neutral, but inside, something possessive and violent clawed its way up my throat.
“How long?”
“A month.”
He flicked ash onto the manicured lawn.
“She’s different from the others. Damaged in all the right ways. Makes her easy to manipulate and mold.”
My jaw clenched.