“Sounded like it,” Mom said, looking between us. “Rachel told me about their mother.” Her mouth pulled down. “Some people shouldn’t be parents.”
“Agreed,” Alex grumbled as he set the burgers on a tray.
“I always felt having a terrible mother was a bigger tragedy. I mean, don’t get me wrong, your father turned out to be pretty awful and I hate that for both of you. But girls need their mother. At least Taylor had her sister, and Rachel raised a beautiful, sweet girl.”
“She did,” I said, softly and a little too quickly.
I scowled at Alex when the corner of his mouth kicked up.
“Wow, this all looks great,” Taylor said, sweeping her hair back into a long ponytail. “Can I help?”
“No, sweetie. You just sit and eat.” Mom patted the chair next to her.
“When do I get to give you dirt on my brother?” Alex asked, holding out the platter of burgers for Taylor. “I’ve been looking forward to this all day.”
“Well, what do you have?” she asked, a playful smile crossing her lips as she took a burger.
“I’ll tell you anything you want to know while I finish up the hot dogs.”
“Okay,” Taylor said, chewing on her lip as she set her burger on her plate. “I’m not recording right now, but I’ll give you the same question I asked your mother. What’s your favorite story about Nate?”
His cocky grin faded as he rested his elbows on the back of one of the chairs.
“I have a few, but it’s a family piece, so I’ll narrow it down to something PG,” he said, his mouth tilting into a smirk. “When he got suspended for me.”
“Suspended from school?”
“From school and his baseball team. He was almost thrown out of both.”
Taylor flinched back and whipped her head to me.
“What did he do?”
“I came out young. I’d just turned sixteen, but to most people who knew me, it wasn’t a plot twist. One of his teammates thought it would be fun to rough up the queer little brother of the best player on the team after school.”
“He beat you up? Oh my God,” Taylor said before her hands flew to her mouth.
“Not really beat me up. He tripped me and peed on my backpack while I was on the floor. My knee was too banged up to fight him back. Mom ran to school and told the coach, and he promised her that the kid would be thrown off the team.” Alex gave Taylor a wistful smile. “But that wasn’t good enough for my brother. Nate waited for him outside school and broke his nose and one or two ribs, I can’t remember.” Alex’s gaze dropped to the ground. “Fighting meant an automatic expulsion.”
“But tripping you and humiliating you wasn’t?” Taylor’s eyes flared. “What bullshit. Sorry,” she said to my mother.
“Don’t be.” She patted Taylor’s arm. “I said the same thing. Bullying was always a gray area in school. They could write it off as ‘boys being boys.’”
“And Nate was up for a baseball scholarship to college at the time,” Alex added. “So if they threw him out, he could have lost everything.”
“I’m sure he was so furious on your behalf he forgot that,” Taylor said, her gaze searching mine like I’d just hung the moon or polished the stars. She’d always looked at me a little like that, but it had never fucked with my head like this. Or made me crave more of it.
All of it.
“No, he knew. Mom even told him to keep his nose clean and let the school handle it. His coach begged the school to keep him, and they were so eager for everyone to forget what had happened and move on, they let him stay after a week suspension.”
“No one was going to get away with doing that to my brother. I’d beat that guy up again tomorrow and wouldn’t care what happened to me after.” I met Alex’s gaze. “And I mean that.”
“I know you do.” Alex blew out a long gust of air. “Idiot.”
Taylor and my mother laughed, my mother’s chuckle a little wet as she wiped at her eyes. She’d both loved and hated that story.
“But if you’re trying to revamp his good image, high school violence, even for the greater good, isn’t acceptable. My brother was the man I could always look up to, even when we were kids. He measured up in ways our father never even came close to.” Alex shoved my shoulder. “And I love his stupid ass for it.”