Vivi set the photograph back in the drawer. “That was nice of your friend to keep sending these.”
“Was it?” Kat gave a little laugh. “I haven’t figured out whether it’s the kindest thing anyone ever did for me or the cruelest.”
“Why cruel?” Vivi asked.
Kat looked down at the family gathered around that long table. “Because she was living the life that should’ve been mine.”
With his hand on her back, he could feel Vivi’s muscles tense. He threw an arm around her shoulder and pulled her close.
Kat slipped the photograph back into the drawer. “In any event, I’ve gotten to watch my nieces and nephews grow up. I saw my parents grow old. I knew when people married and when babies arrived.” She closed the drawer. “I watched from afar.”
“Did your friend reach out when your husband died?” Vivi asked.
“No.” Kat forced a smile. “Maybe that answers my question.” She moved to the last drawer on the far right and pulled out the cake slicer. Holding it up, she said, “Let’s try that cake.”
They followed her back into the kitchen. “What’re you doing when the market closes?” Vivi asked.
Kat waved a hand. “Well, I live here. I’ll go on about my life.”
“Why don’t you come to Calamity Falls for New Year’s Eve?” Jack asked. “My daughter runs the inn. I'll get you the best room in the house.”
“Does this best room have a view?”
“Of the Tetons. It’s so pretty you'll cry.”
“I never cry.” Kat set a slice of cake on a pretty dessert plate. “I'll think about it.”
By eleven, the neighborhood had quieted down. Christmas lights outlined café windows and curled around the trees, and the shops along Rue Saint-Honoré were still lit up. A few people passed them bundled in coats, and every so often, a car or scooter went by.
Vivi kept her chin down, hands buried in her pockets.
“I imagine that hit close to home,” he said quietly.
“Different situation, but yeah.” She kept a brisk pace. “I get the culture of a family. Mine certainly had one. Dad was the focal point, and Mom served him. The kids came way down on the list. The thing I don’t get is why, years later, the entire family would continue to have no contact with Kat. Where’s the forgiveness? As a mother or a sister, wouldn’t you miss her so badly you’d reach out? I just hate that she’s paying for a choice she made as a teenager.”
There wasn’t much he could say to make sense of it. “My parents spent years begging me to talk to my brother. They blamed me for destroying the family. I loved my folks, I did. But I really wanted my mom to say, ‘I’m sorry for the way we let Grant destroy this family.’”
She linked her arm through his and pulled him close. "You're so right. She just wanted the easy child to keep making it easy for her."
They stopped at the light at Boulevard des Capucines. Gold lights wrapped the trees, storefronts glowed red and green, and the buildings were washed in warm white light.
A memory tugged at him. Christmas morning. He was eight years old, handing his little red Matchbox car to his brother. He could still feel the sting in his eyes, and the way he’d held his breath so he wouldn't cry.
The light changed, and he shook it off. They stepped into the crosswalk.
“Do you think her friend is kind or cruel to send those pictures?” Vivi asked.
“If Kat wrote her and told her to stop, that it was hurting her, and she kept sending them, it would be cruel.”
“But if she didn’t, then it means Kat wants this glimpse into their lives.”
“She said she’s reached out over the years, but no one’s responded.” And that was the part that had to upset Vivi.
He couldn’t fix her situation with her kids. But he could make her tea while she got ready for bed. He could hold her till she fell asleep—he’d learned she liked that. Practically purred like a kitten when he wrapped his arms around her.
It might not be much, but there were small things he could do to give her comfort.
“Do you think my kids will ever come around?” she asked.