“Believe me, no one finds that harder to understand than I do.”
But wait, Jack Holland had a crush on me?
“I figured I hadn’t known you at all. But here’s the thing. The woman who raised three decent kids, started philanthropies, and ran galas? That’s someone who knows how to make the best of a bad situation. Not someone who steals money and abandons her family. So, no, the rumors didn’t ring true, but I also didn’t have the whole story.”
“That’s a really good way to look at it.” She looked down at her hands. “I did try to make the best of it.” She sat with it for a moment until her fingers curled into fists. “I just can’t stand what he took from me.” A tumult of emotion overpowered her, and she couldn’t hold back. “I knew he’d make my life difficult, but I never dreamed he’d turn my children against me.”
He set the knife and block of wood on the shop rag. “I can’t imagine anything crueler.”
“I mean, they’re adults now. They must see Grant for who he is. They know how irrational he sounds when he’s trying to win an argument. They know when they’re being gaslit. They know he uses money to keep them in line.”
“Are they close with him?”
“They won’t ‘rehash the past’ with me, so I can’t say for sure. But from what I can piece together, I don’t think so.”
“I get it. My ex-wife had Willa believing I had no aspirations beyond keeping the cookie basket in the lobby filled. It was a subtle campaign waged over eighteen years, and it worked. Willa left to follow in her mom's footsteps."
“What made her finally come back to you?”
“Her mother.” He grinned. “Just like you said, she finally saw Elizabeth for who she was and decided she didn’t want to be anything like her.”
“Well, Harper’s about the same age as your daughter, and she’s definitely not coming back to me.” She hadn’t ever talked about what happened in the weeks before the divorce, but the hum of the engines, the darkened cabin, and the kind man beside her made her feel safe enough to let it out. “I think it’s because Grant involved them.”
“Involved them how?”
“A month before I was going to move out, I found Nolan on my computer. He was eleven at the time, so it didn’t make a lot of sense. What did he care about his mom’s emails or social calendar? I thought it was odd, but I let it go. Then, when Grant locked me out of the house, I couldn’t figure out how he’d found out my plans. But I thought back to my son’s expression when I caught him. Because, sure, there was guilt, but there was anger, too. I think Grant became suspicious and used Nolan to get my passwords.”
“Jesus, Viv. That’s horrible. I hate to think what he said to get him to betray his own mother.”
“Well, we know that now, right? Grant probably told him I was running away with another man and stealing his money. And he had my journals.” She hadn't said that out loud in years. “They were in a box right inside the front door. I could see it through the glass. Fifteen years of me ranting about how much I hated my life. How badly I wanted a different one.” She swallowed. “I never saw them again. But I bet he read every page, and every time I wrote about wanting out, his twisted mind turned it into me running off with someone.”
Jack's jaw went tight.
“And there’s another thing. Nolan was obsessed with hockey. If Grant thought his son was any good, he’d have been all in, but Nolan hadn’t developed yet, and he was one of the weaker players. Grant was so disgusted, he stopped going to games. So, I bet he promised to keep paying for hockey if Nolan helped him.”
“I’m glad Willa’s not here to monitor my blood pressure right now.”
“It gets worse. When I was locked out, I kept looking for another way into the house. A window. Anything. And then I saw my daughter upstairs, and I thought, Oh, thank God. I waved for her to let me in.” For a moment, the cabin fell away. She was outside that house again, waving at her little girl. Her chest tightened, but she had to get it out. Had to finish the story. “She just stared at me for a second and then walked away.”
“I can’t imagine manipulating your children like that.” He shook his head in disgust. “I’m sorry, Vivi. That man is pure evil.”
“He is. But I think making them complicit did a number on them.”
“It would have to. I don’t know how a child would process that.”
“I’ve spent a lot of time in therapy, trying to make sense of things, and here’s the thing. My children knew me. I was the one who read to them, bathed them, and made their favorite foods. I made the magic for birthdays and holidays. How could they reconcile the mother they knew with the woman their father described?”
Jack watched her with such compassion that she felt truly, deeply seen and heard. “They do know you, Vivi. Deep down, they remember.”
And even though nothing in her life changed, some small part of her healed. “Well, I’ll never stop trying.” That was for sure. “I stayed in town until Nolan left for college, and I come back on every birthday, holiday, and anniversary. One day, I hope they’ll let me in.”
“Maybe, instead of going to see them, you could invite them into your world.”
“What do you mean? They don’t want to visit me in Silverbrush.” Over the years, the old mining town had transformed from a hippie commune into an artist’s colony. Now, it was a thriving community of studios and outdoorsy health nuts. They had a theater, a small organic grocer, and loads of charming B&Bs with windchimes that could be heard from one end of town to the other.
But her kids weren’t artists, and Grant had raised them to think creative people were lazy and wanted an easy life.
“But would they come to Paris?” Jack asked.